Agree Hal offers almost nothing, rccl is a distant third . Was totally blown away with my MSc yacht club equal or superior to celebrity suites . Butler does a better job they will escort you to shows or off the ship etc , our butler carried our drinks from lounge to restaurant each night. They’re the only suite lounge with live music most of the night . Very similar outdoor area with Edge class with outdoor pool , bar but superior outdoor restaurant . I do like the celebrity bigger suites with free specialty restaurants and bar setup . But MSc offers some small bottles of liquor in your fridge.