Freedom is my pang-y love. I know it's partly because it was a special vacation when I sailed on her. It just felt like there was so much space, so much outdoor open space in particular. (With access to the heli pad on the bow!) I met a lot of really friendly folks on that ship too, it just had a great relaxing vibe.
I really love the Oasis class too with so much to do, but then Anthem is dreamy--I'm an outlier, maybe--I think 270 is just the bees knees.
My first cruise was with my parents when I was a young adult on Song of America. Amazing memories of that version of cruising too. SO fancy.
I'm the opposite of the complainers--I could make a list of 20 things that make each ship I've been on "the best."