I am a for real foodie.
IMO the commentary about the quality of food is grossly overexaggerated. My most recent sailing was on Allure the week of 10/1. I was expecting the worst.
The majority of my meals were quite good. We ate at the MDR 4 our of the 7 nights and Specialty the remaining nights. I honestly was surprised that the food was as good as it was given the sentiment on this board. We had MTD and we asked for the same server each night. We also tipped our server team each night. I am not sure if that had anything to do with our good experience. But we never had any awful or cold food.
We had a great cruise in regards to the food. The demographic onboard was a totally different experience, however. But that is a topic for a different thread.