I just got it to work for Cheers, 12:05 AM eastern time with the original pricing of $51.95. I logged out and logged back in before trying it just to refresh my session and make sure the pricing had not changed. Good luck if you try again.
Edit: 12:22 AM - I see the prices have changed now. I did check my confirmation email and the pricing I got was definately the old price tiers. I guess I got lucky, hope some of you kept trying and did as well.