St John or Jt Thomas???

Which would you do with 1 day? Why? HELP..............

St John's Trunk Bay is by far the most beautiful beach I've ever been to. St Thomas is much more commercial, but offers Magen's Bay. If you're looking for tranquil beach time - catch the ferry to St John and enjoy a peaceful day at Trunk Bay. Magen's Bay is gorgeous - but often more crowded. If you're looking for shopping, etc - St Thomas is a better choice.

St. John's, unless you like crowds or want to shop. If you have time to take an island tour, do it. Almost all of St. John's is a park, lovely. The tour will take you by several beaches as well as Hurricane Hole and old sugar cane plantation areas.

I agree with the other posters.

Shopping - St. Thomas

Beaches - St. John