Coco Reef vs Elbow Beach Day Pass

Has anyone done both the Coco Reef and Elbow Beach day passes on different trips to Bermuda? If so, what are your thoughts on each. I do realize that the Coco Reef pass includes lunch and use of the pool. It is imperative that I have shade while visiting, and both offer spots with umbrellas. We have been to Coco Reef several years ago, but never to Elbow Beach. Do the umbrellas at Elbow provide enough cover to keep all/most of you out of the direct sun? Any comparisons would be most helpful. Thanks!

Also, is the restaurant at Elbow Beach (Mickey's) covered?

Thanks!

never done the day pass, but yes Mickey's has areas that are fully covered.