Rose Island vs Pearl Island

Cruising on Mariner of the Seas in March. We’re planning on doing either of those islands. Just wondering if anyone has done both and which they prefer. Or if you’ve done one of them, what you liked about it. TIA.

I would highly recommend Roses Island (though I haven't done Pearl Island)

Here is a review I wrote:

The only place I will ever go if we visit Nassau in the future is Roses Island with www.sandytoesbahamas.com. Absolutely amazing!!! Arrival and departure was super-timely (which I was worried about), and no issue getting a cab on either end.

Upon arrival, we relaxed at the most beautiful beach. We then walked to the left over the rocks, and found a private beach that we had to ourselves for about an hour. The water was the cleanest - you could see your toes and all the fish vividly.

Lunch was great. And all of the staff was super nice!

The pigs were a bit anti-climatic. I would skip that part next time. I am not a fan of things that feel staged, which it was, but it was also obvious that they were very well taken care of. Those pigs are living a fine life in exchange to visiting with the tourists each day.

Let me know if you have any questions.