Jump to content

Leaving ship before reaching final port?


DAllenTCY
 Share

Recommended Posts

I would double check with Princess. It doesn't sound like you will violate the Passenger Services Act (aka Jones Act) and you will probably be allowed to but I would encourage you to speak with Princess before making plans.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Someone got off our cruise a day early in France rather than going back to Southampton. I wish we had thought of doing just that and had spend a night or 2 in Paris. They arranged it ahead of time with Princess and we watched them leave with their bags on the 2nd to last day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As Coral mentioned, there would be a problem with PSA if you decided to disembark in San Diego. You would each be assessed a fine of $300 for the violation. Something similar happened recently on an X cruise, where a couple disembarked in SD for a family emergency, and had to pay the fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hi all:

 

we took a cruise a couple of years ago from san diego to vancouver on the radiance of the seas. hubby wanted to get off 2 days early in astoria, oregon because he's afraid of flying and just wanted to drive home. i stayed on the cruise the 2 extra days, but they charged him $300 to get off the cruise early. wonder what would happen if he just left and didn't say he was gonna get off early.

 

dave and gerry

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hi all:

 

we took a cruise a couple of years ago from san diego to vancouver on the radiance of the seas. hubby wanted to get off 2 days early in astoria, oregon because he's afraid of flying and just wanted to drive home. i stayed on the cruise the 2 extra days, but they charged him $300 to get off the cruise early. wonder what would happen if he just left and didn't say he was gonna get off early.

 

dave and gerry

 

I know someone who missed the ship in Alaska and had to pay the fine...My guess is that you would get charged for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dawn Princess does not go to a distant foreign port (as defined by the act) and therefore pax cannot disembark in a US port other than the one they embarked in without violating the act and incurring the fine.

 

Thanks for the clarification - I wasn't sure if this cruise would allow it or not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm more confused now than before. If Puerto Vallarta, Mazatlan, and Cabo aren't distant foreign ports, that what are they? How can Ensenada be a foreign port on Hawaiian round trips? Also, the Dawn Princess goes through US Customs in San Diego, so why can't one disembark there? Where is defined that one must disembark at the same port as they embarked? What about repositioning cruises?

Jeees!

Me

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welcome to the wonderful world of protectionist law!

 

The Passenger Service Act (incorrectly called the Jones Act) prevents any foreign-flagged vessel from transporting passengers between any two United States ports without first stopping at a so-called "distant foreign port". Distant ports, to keep it simple, would be in South America or further away.

 

To further complicate things, even on a round trip cruise, at least one foreign port (distant or otherwise) must be visited. That's why Hawaiin cruises stop at Ensenada.

 

I'm sure you'll get much more information than you bargained for, just because you asked. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"wonder what would happen if he just left and didn't say he was gonna get off early."

 

When you leave the ship, you have to insert your cabin card in the machine that keeps track of who left the ship. They'll know if you haven't boarded again.

 

If you go on the Alaskan Inside Passage cruises on Princess, there's a stop in Victoria, BC for the same reason the Island Princess stops in Ensenada: the dreaded PSA.

 

The NCL America ships are exempt because they are not foreign-flagged. But the NCL ship that goes from the west coast to Hawaii stops at Fanning Island.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would check with Princess, I doubt there would be a problem as you have gone thru US customs in San Diego.

 

In 1999 I did an Alaska repo from Vancouver to Alaksa, then down to LA on the Celebrity Mercury. Since I live in the San Francisco area I wanted to get off the ship there and skip the last day down to LA. This was no big deal, about a dozen of us did this. We met customs in an onboard lounge that morning, filled out some forms and were let off the ship. No problems, no fine and very easy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....in order to travel between two US ports (SF, San Diego) on a foreign vessel (Princess), you would need to stop at a "distant foreign port." None of the Mexican ports of call will meet this requirement. So, I believe you'll have to continue through to your embarkation port for a roundtrip that only requires stopping at a "foreign port" -- satisfied by any of your Mexican ports.

 

The repositioning cruises that you're thinking of that involve two US ports (ie: Ft. Lauderdale - SF, via the Panama Canal) stop in Aruba to comply with the law, because Aruba (unlike most Caribbean ports) is considered a "distant foreign port."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And a voyage that originates or ends in Mexico or Canada does not transport passengers between 2 US ports, so they don't have to comply with the 'distant foreign port' issue. That is why a Vancouver-LA cruise would not have a problem with a SF disembarkation and why one-way Hawaii cruisers embark in Ensenada.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....in order to travel between two US ports (SF, San Diego) on a foreign vessel (Princess), you would need to stop at a "distant foreign port." None of the Mexican ports of call will meet this requirement. So, I believe you'll have to continue through to your embarkation port for a roundtrip that only requires stopping at a "foreign port" -- satisfied by any of your Mexican ports.
I'm afraid that this isn't completely accurate. It is the Jones Act that requires cruise ships to be US flagged if they depart/return to a US port. Getting a ship US flagged is expensive, so the cruise lines don't do it. The Jones Act also allows a cruise ship to depart and return to a US port if the ship makes at least ONE call in a non-US port.It doesn't matter if the foreign port is 20 miles away or 200 miles away, it just has to be a non-US country. That is why cruises that depart from Seattle and cruise Alaska have a port call at either Victoria for a couple of hours in the late evening or some other Canadian port. NCL got a special waiver in order to cruise just the Hawaiian Islands by promising to have the majority of the ships crew be American.

 

This is a little off track of the original question, but it is more accurate.

 

The answer as so many have already said is yes you can get off a cruise at a different port. In fact I know of several people who have used a short carnival cruise to make a on way trip to Cozumel and take a huge amount of luggage with them. It was less expensive than flying and shipping the stuff.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Distance has nothing to do with it. This is why you can take the 4 day cruises out of LA that go to San Diego, Ensenada and Catalina Island and still comply with the act. You could not go from San Francisco and get off in San Diego without FIRST going to Mexico under the Jones Act, but if you go to Mexico first, then get off in San Diego on the way home, it would appear to comply.

 

Round trip cruises from San Diego or LA to Hawaii now only stop in Ensenada for 1-4 hours....Ensenada is only 90 miles from San Diego, so certainly is not "distant".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't consider Victoria, BC to be a distant foreign port. But, In June, Princess allowed us to disembark in Victoria a day early, rather than go back to Seattle. We hadn't planned this in advance, just did it on the ship on our way to Victoria! I also used my cell phone to get a reservation at a hotel! We weren't charged anything!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Distance has nothing to do with it. This is why you can take the 4 day cruises out of LA that go to San Diego, Ensenada and Catalina Island and still comply with the act. You could not go from San Francisco and get off in San Diego without FIRST going to Mexico under the Jones Act, but if you go to Mexico first, then get off in San Diego on the way home, it would appear to comply.

 

Round trip cruises from San Diego or LA to Hawaii now only stop in Ensenada for 1-4 hours....Ensenada is only 90 miles from San Diego, so certainly is not "distant".

Round trips do not require a distant port. Panama Canal trips from FL to CA stop in Aruba because that is considered the distant port. On our trip from San Diego to Hawaii we went to the port of SD to check in, turned in our bags which were loaded on the ship, the ship sailed to Ensenada, we were bussed to Ensenada to embark on the ship.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Jones Act also allows a cruise ship to depart and return to a US port if the ship makes at least ONE call in a non-US port.It doesn't matter if the foreign port is 20 miles away or 200 miles away, it just has to be a non-US country.

 

As long as it's a roundtrip, that's true. But, if embarkation and disembarkation are at two separate ports, it matters:

"....voyages by foreign vessels between two U.S. ports that include a distant foreign port,and round trip voyages from U.S. ports that include a nearby foreign port and other U.S. ports, do not violate the PVSA." http://www.gao.gov/docdblite/details.php?rptno=GAO-04-421

 

There must be a "distant foreign port" involved when embarking and disembarking at two separate US ports; only a "foreign port" is required for a roundtrip involving one US port. Though, as someone said "distant" is in the eye of the Passenger Services Act, not the map. Aruba qualifies, Bermuda doesn't.

 

In fact I know of several people who have used a short carnival cruise to make a on way trip to Cozumel and take a huge amount of luggage with them. It was less expensive than flying and shipping the stuff.

 

That shouldn't be a problem, because you are embarking in the US, and terminating in a foreign port. The problem only really arises when you are dealing with US roundtrips involving either the same port or two different US ports.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't consider Victoria, BC to be a distant foreign port. But, In June, Princess allowed us to disembark in Victoria a day early, rather than go back to Seattle. We hadn't planned this in advance, just did it on the ship on our way to Victoria! I also used my cell phone to get a reservation at a hotel! We weren't charged anything!

 

That didn't violate the law since you got off in Canada. The problems arise when you are traveling between two US ports. It is even true if you combine cruises. The only thing the law cares about is where you embark, and where you disembark. If those points are located in the US, there must be a call at a distant foreign port. That is why you cannot combine repo cruises, such as Seattle-Vancouver then Vancouver-Los Angeles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would double check with Princess. It doesn't sound like you will violate the Passenger Services Act (aka Jones Act) and you will probably be allowed to but I would encourage you to speak with Princess before making plans.

As long as the ship has been at one foreign port before the OP disembarks, it's fine. But, if there has been no foreign port yet, disembarking before making that foreign port will not be allowed except in an emergency.

 

I took the Island Princess Circle Hawaii from San Pedro. Apparently some people decided to just disembark at one of the Hawaiin islands without discussing it with anybody from Princess. The cruise director ... in a coffee chat one day on the way back from the islands to San Pedro ... told us that this couple both got assessed a hefty fine ... something like five grand ... for violating the Jones Act. We were not due to hit our foreign port ... Enseneda, Mexico ... until the last day of the cruise.

 

Of course, though, he said that in the case of an emergency requiring a passenger to leave the ship to fly home, exceptions can and are made.

 

Blue skies ...

 

--rita

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You will get no refund of unused days.

Yeah, but the price might be prorated in the brochure depending upon where you are going to disembark. I've seen cruises advertised with three prices ... depending on whether you are planning to disembark in say Los Angeles, Seattle or Vancouver.

 

The OP's cruise may have a similar offering, in which case she wouldn't be charged as much as someone staying on for the additional day or two to get to a farther distant disembarkation point.

 

Blue skies ...

 

--rita

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share

  • Forum Jump
    • Categories
      • Welcome to Cruise Critic
      • New Cruisers
      • Cruise Lines “A – O”
      • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
      • River Cruising
      • ROLL CALLS
      • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
      • Special Interest Cruising
      • Cruise Discussion Topics
      • UK Cruising
      • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
      • Canadian Cruisers
      • North American Homeports
      • Ports of Call
      • Cruise Conversations
×
×
  • Create New...