Is the smell of smoke a problem at the front of the Eclipse?

[Jo and Rob]

I've read a couple of threads stating that the smell of smoke can be a real problem on the port side of the ship on deck 6. My question is has anyone on deck 7 experienced a problem and if the answer is yes, was it towards the front of the ship?

many thanks

[lvcruiser]

Double post.

[lvcruiser]

Only when those pesky smoked salmon light up before the ship runs them over and serves them for dinner.

 

Seriously, your question is valid and for the reasons stated, I have booked my cruise on the Eclipse in December in a cabin on the starboard side of the ship. At this point, I cannot give you any advice on the matter since I have yet to sail on the ship.

[txsloth]

There are two older ships in this class, and one review all of a sudden has everyone in a panic over smoke from the 5th deck. The previous two ships in this class had the exact same layout, including smoking areas, and I don't recall one earlier complaint about smelling smoke. I really think it's a rare occurence (not picking on you Jo and Rob, that one review has lead to a bunch of similar threads).

[Jo and Rob]

There are two older ships in this class, and one review all of a sudden has everyone in a panic over smoke from the 5th deck. The previous two ships in this class had the exact same layout, including smoking areas, and I don't recall one earlier complaint about smelling smoke. I really think it's a rare occurence (not picking on you Jo and Rob, that one review has lead to a bunch of similar threads).

 

You are right sometimes one thread does cause a panic. We have already changed our cabin once to get a bunk after being informed here that a double sofa bed only sleeps one! so I do take these boards seriously. As to the double thread comment, I did not want to hijack a thread about a mid-ship deck six location (I did check the deck plans before I posted to see whether I was close to the earlier threads location and I am not)