Liberty Rm 7434 or an Aft Cabin??

[Yingus]

Looking to do the Liberty next winter.... Wondering if we should take room 7434 with the bigger balcony or spend another 130.00 for one of the aft balcony's on the same floor. Any thoughts? Thanks!

[bazarr2]

Looking to do the Liberty next winter.... Wondering if we should take room 7434 with the bigger balcony or spend another 130.00 for one of the aft balcony's on the same floor. Any thoughts? Thanks!

From what some say about that odd shaped cabin is it is cramped because of the odd shape. The balcony looks nice.

http://www.cruisedeckplans.com/DP/zenphoto/index.php?album=Carnival+Liberty%2FCat+Balcony%2FStateroom+7434#8

[CanWeGoYet?]

I had an L shaped cabin on the deck below. I loved it. The cabin did not seem cramped to me, but there was just me and my son. We loved the double long balcony. I'd book another L shaped cabin in a heartbeat.

 

It's not as great as an aft wrap, but this cabin cost less than the average balcony. I don't know if they have changed the category to raise the price by now. I would rather have this one though than a regular aft. The balcony is longer, and we had no problem with soot or people throwing garbage on it from above.

[pe4all]

It's not as great as an aft wrap, but this cabin cost less than the average balcony. I don't know if they have changed the category to raise the price by now.

They did change the category/price of these cabins. I also had one (7434 on Liberty) when it was an 8B - great steal at that price. They are now "premium" cabins. It was definitely smaller (no sofa) than a regular cabin, but the balcony was great. It all depends how much time you will spend in the cabin as compared to the balcony.