ElmaLee Posted August 20, 2023 #251 Share Posted August 20, 2023 Date of Cruise: 12 Aug 2023 Ship: Edge Cabin #: 10128 Deck #: 10 Cabin Category:c2 Cabin Location: Mid Bed Position: By window Balcony Type: IV Balcony/Window Size: Large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: No Magic Carpet Issues?: N/A Noise Issues?: No Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: Connects to 10126 Advantages/Problems/Comments: Handy for elevators. No noise problems Would You Book It Again?: yes Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
poochi24 Posted August 30, 2023 #252 Share Posted August 30, 2023 Date of Cruise: 8/9/2023 Ship: Apex Cabin #: 12189 and 12182 Deck #:12 Cabin Category:Concierge class Cabin Location: Midship Bed Position: 12189 had bed close to balcony; 12182 had bed close to the door Balcony Type: infinite verandah Balcony/Window Size: Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: see comments Balcony Overhang?: 12182- from magic carpet Magic Carpet Issues?: simple panoramic photos left to right of the window capture the magic carpet in your photos Noise Issues?: Both rooms had creaking at night, 12189 could hear pool chairs in the morning at 5am Wind Issues?: n/a Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: n/a Suite Details: Advantages/Problems/Comments: 12182 could see parts of magic carpet when you look out the window towards the left; on the right, there was a weird hinge thing that might be part of a motor? not sure what it was. 12189 had obstruction with this slanted beam smack 1/3 of the way of the window on the left; the right side also had a semicircle protrusion- not sure what it was either. sofa was visiblity dirty in 12189 (like smudge marks and skid marks from a tire or something) Would You Book It Again?: maybe Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dani negreanu Posted November 5, 2023 #253 Share Posted November 5, 2023 Date of Cruise: 02/09/23 Ship: Edge Cabin #: 12196 Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: C1 Cabin Location: Mid ship near the Elevators Bed Position: Next to balcony Balcony Type: IV Balcony/Window Size: Standard IV Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: Yes Magic Carpet Issues?: None Noise Issues?: None Wind Issues?: None Connecting Cabin? : No Advantages/Problems/Comments: Excellent location. BUT, being under the OCV, I've checked very carefully the deck plans, and found this cabin which is located just under the ladies RR, so no noise of moving chairs/tables... Would You Book It Again?: Yes Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
wineoclock Posted November 8, 2023 #254 Share Posted November 8, 2023 Date ofCruise: 20th October 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin#: 12172 Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: Magic carpet Suite Cabin Location: Midship Bed Position: Bathroom Balcony Type: Standard Balcony/Window Size: Fairly large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Magic Carpet visible if on deck 14 Balcony Overhang?: Yes Magic Carpet Issues?: Not much Noise Issues?: No only when magic carpet moving and sometimes banging but not too bad WindIssues?: Only if balcony door left open a tad Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No SuiteDetails: Large room great balcony with 2 sun loungers as well as 2 chairs and small table Advantages/Problems/Comments: Great to have large balcony when with MC obstructing view at times Would You Book It Again?: if price right. Wouldn’t pay full price I don’t think Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brucemcdou Posted November 16, 2023 #255 Share Posted November 16, 2023 On 11/23/2018 at 4:05 PM, vtcruising said: Date of Cruise: November 5, 2023 (WB Transatlantic ) Ship: Apex Cabin #: 11201 Deck #: 11 Cabin Category: SS Cabin Location: Aft by rear elevator bank Bed Position: Facing balcony Balcony Type: Real balcony, sliding door Balcony/Window Size: Large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Pole in balcony by railing ; about 1/3 of the way from the left side of balcony Not an issue Balcony Overhang?: Deck 14 overhang two decks above; not an issue Magic Carpet Issues?: N/A; cabin on port side Noise Issues?: None Wind Issues?: Crossing had many windy/cool days so did not use balcony that much. Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: N/A Suite Details: Advantages/Problems/Comments: Convenient for aft elevators and only two decks below buffet/pool. However , longer walk forward to luminae and retreat lounge. Not a big deal. Would You Book It Again?: yes, but would prefer no pole on balcony. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GenXer85 Posted November 18, 2023 #256 Share Posted November 18, 2023 (edited) Date of Cruise: 1. October 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 8334 Deck #: 9 Cabin Category: Sunset Verandah Cabin Location: Aft, long walk to elevator Bed Position: Near bath Balcony Type: Traditional walk out balcony Balcony/Window Size: Not as wide as other balconies around. I had to ask for a lounger and they removed it last night probably because less spacious than others Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: Yes, and good for privacy from above Magic Carpet Issues?: None Noise Issues?: None, very quiet Wind Issues?: None Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No Suite Details: NA Advantages/Problems/Comments: Only issue was that the wardrobe/closet was parallel and close to the the bed so it was not convenient to get into it especially if other person in room was sitting on that side of the bed. Would You Book It Again?: yes Edited November 18, 2023 by GenXer85 more info Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tuffy0317 Posted November 26, 2023 #257 Share Posted November 26, 2023 Date of Cruise: 22 Nov 2023 Ship: Ascent Cabin #: 11159 Deck #: 11 Cabin Category: C1 Cabin Location: Mid Bed Position: By door Balcony Type: Standard Edge class Balcony/Window Size: Standard Edge class Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Yes - significant overhang from deck 12 Balcony Overhang?: Yes - significant Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: No Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? N/A Connect?: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: Very quiet; sometimes window did not work to lower (buttons would stick) Would You Book It Again?: yes Photos or Photo Links: 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spammie Posted November 30, 2023 #258 Share Posted November 30, 2023 Date of Cruise: 13 Nov 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 10168 Deck #: 10 Cabin Category: MS - Magic Carpet Suite Cabin Location: Mid Bed Position: By door Balcony Type: Very large regular balcony with side window Balcony/Window Size: Very large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Yes - large overhang from the magic carpet Balcony Overhang?: Yes - significant Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: YES Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? N/A Connect?: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: Extremely LOUD! We were only in this cabin for two nights before they moved us to Suite 10147. The banging, cracking and popping noise coming from the ceiling was insane! Would You Book It Again?: NO Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
spammie Posted November 30, 2023 #259 Share Posted November 30, 2023 Date of Cruise: 13 Nov 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 10147 Deck #: 10 Cabin Category: S1 Sky Suite Cabin Location: Mid Bed Position: Facing the ocean Balcony Type: Regular balcony Balcony/Window Size: Large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: No Balcony Overhang?: Yes Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: No Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? N/A Connect?: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: We were moved to this cabin due to extreme ceiling noise issues from our original MC suite 10168. We loved everything about this suite! The layout was amazing and so was the location and storage. Would You Book It Again?: Yes Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mrgabriel Posted January 2 #260 Share Posted January 2 (edited) Date of Cruise: December 23-31, 2023 Ship: Ascent Cabin #: 9245 Deck #: 9 Cabin Category: AQ Cabin Location: Aft. About 5 cabins from the aft elevators Bed Position: By Window Balcony Type: Infinite Verandah Balcony/Window Size: Standard Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: There is a lifeboat below but this cabin juts out a bit so the lifeboat was only visible when you looked straight down with the 'balcony' open. Balcony Overhang?: Not really. Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: Very quiet. Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? No. Where Does it Connect?: Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: PROS: Nice cabin in a perfect location by the elevator. CONS: We didn't like the infinite verandah. Personal preference. Would You Book It Again?: No. If we travel on an E-class ship again we would not book a cabin with an infinite verandah. But we would definitely sail on this ship again, either in an Oceanview or regular cabin. Edited January 2 by mrgabriel Formatting 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare Terre Posted January 8 #261 Share Posted January 8 (edited) Date of Cruise: 12/11/2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 12164 Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: Concierge Cabin Location: Midship Bed Position: Queen Balcony Type: Infinite Veranda Balcony/Window Size: Balcony/Window/View Obstruction: yes Balcony Overhang? yes Magic Carpet Issues: yes, superstructure for MC obstructed our view Noise Issues?: yes, creaking, popping, cracking all night and during the day Wind Issues? no Connecting Cabin? Where does it connect?: no Suite Details: n/a Advantages/Problems/Comments: close to elevator; under the Magic Carpet which made cabin very noisy, unable to sleep, even with ear plugs; Magic Carpet superstructure obscured half of our view; folding doors would not close, so when we opened the window to the Infinite Veranda, the entire cabin fogged up with moisture from the outside humidity--walls, mirrors, etc. Would not get another Infinite Veranda Would you book it again?: no Photos or Photo Links: Edited January 8 by Terre Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Pushkin Posted January 23 #262 Share Posted January 23 Date of Cruise: January 14-21, 2024 Ship: Ascent Cabin #: 6135 Deck #: 6 Cabin Category: POV (Panoramic Ocean View) Cabin Location: Port/FWD Bed Position: By Window Balcony Type: N/A Balcony/Window Size: Panoramic - outside wall all window (IV window, but did not open) Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: There is a lifeboat below, and superstructure above (overhang) Overhang?: Yes. Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: Very noisy - clinking, clanging, banging (mentioned to Guest Relations - the problem was fixed - no noise for remainder of cruise) Wind Issues?: N/A Connecting Cabin? No. Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: PROS: Nice sized cabin in a convenient location by the FWD elevator. CONS: Was very creaky (corrected on 3rd day), foul odor in hallway, Between the location of the lifeboat below and the overhand above, it was too obstructed for us Would You Book It Again?: We would not book this cabin category again, but do love the Ascent, in general.IMG_3792.HEIC IMG_3792.HEIC IMG_3791.HEIC IMG_3790.HEIC Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DeckDad Posted February 4 #263 Share Posted February 4 On 3/30/2022 at 2:37 PM, brooker said: Date of Cruise: JANUARY 2024 Ship: Apex Cabin #: 7134 Deck #: 7 Cabin Category: infinite veranda Cabin Location: Forward Bed Position: Near bathroom Balcony Type: infinite veranda Balcony/Window Size: Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: none, view of some sort of square ladder tower but only went up to deck 6 Balcony Overhang?: Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: No Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: Yes to an adjoining IV. Suite Details: Advantages/Problems/Comments: Close to forward elevators. Would You Book It Again?: Absolutely Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
anon60 Posted February 15 #264 Share Posted February 15 Date of Cruise: February 4th-15th 2024 Ship: Edge Cabin #: 10222 Deck #: 10 Cabin Category: AQ1 Cabin Location: Aft. About 10 cabins from the aft elevators Bed Position: By door Balcony Type: Infinite Verandah Balcony/Window Size: Standard Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None. This cabin got a lot of flack due to a post saying it gives a tunnel feeling. No tunnel feeling. Lovely, lit, well kept cabin. The infinite veranda made for a more spacious stateroom. No obstructions from either left or right. Balcony Overhang?: Not really. Magic Carpet Issues?: No. The magic carpet is midship. We could see where it was at any given time but it did not disturb us nor did its supporting poles. Noise Issues?: Very quiet. Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? No. Where Does it Connect?: Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: PROS: Nice quiet cabin in a perfect location by the elevator. CONS: None we could find Would You Book It Again?: Yes although for the variety I would like to try a cabin on the other side too (Edge docks and tenders from the magic carpet side). VID-20240204-WA0006.mp4 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare bjahil47 Posted February 21 #265 Share Posted February 21 When was the spreadsheet last updated? All I see is Edge on there. Thanks.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Chip28 Posted February 21 #266 Share Posted February 21 10 hours ago, bjahil47 said: When was the spreadsheet last updated? All I see is Edge on there. Thanks.. I think I saw that the person that originally devised this spreadsheet sadly died suddenly Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
3boyz2keep Posted February 24 #267 Share Posted February 24 (edited) Date of Cruise: 09 Feb 2024 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 9206 Deck #: 9 Cabin Category: S3 Cabin Location: Mid Bed Position: By Cabin Door Balcony Type: Verandah Balcony/Window Size: Large Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: Yes Magic Carpet Issues?: NO Noise Issues?: Some banging in rough seas Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: Connects to an IV cabin from hallway, not in cabin itself. Advantages/Problems/Comments: We loved this cabin! Huge balcony with 2 loungers, 2 chairs and a small table and window to the aft of the ship. We've booked the same cabin on the XCEL. Would You Book It Again?: YES Photos or Photo Links: Edited February 24 by 3boyz2keep 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hoya2112 Posted March 4 #268 Share Posted March 4 (edited) Date of Cruise: Feb 24, 2024 Ship: Apex Cabin #: 12210 Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: C2 Cabin Location: Mid ship near the Elevators Bed Position: Nearer to door Balcony Type: IV Balcony/Window Size: Standard IV Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: Yes Magic Carpet Issues?: None Noise Issues?: Yes Wind Issues?: None Connecting Cabin? : No Advantages/Problems/Comments: Excellent location stateroom attendant is 5-stars. We stayed in this cabin in 2023 and this sailing so we knew it was below OCV cafe and we know the sound of carts rolling across the floor. The noise problem is NONE of this. Outside the cabin in the ceiling panels was likely pipes banging on each other or the ceiling occurring during during rougher sea days. Sounds like two empty soda cans banging on each other. Goes on all night. I slept two nights with noise cancelling headphones. Maintenance couldn’t fix it. Would You Book It Again?: Heck no Photos or Photo Links: Edited March 4 by Hoya2112 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hoya2112 Posted March 4 #269 Share Posted March 4 (edited) Edited March 4 by Hoya2112 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lara h Posted March 10 #270 Share Posted March 10 (edited) Deck #: 7/315 EDGE Feb 2024 Cabin Category: Sunset Veranda Cabin Location: Aft. Middle Bed Position: By wardrobe Balcony Type: Sunset Veranda Balcony/Window Size: Deep and wide with 2 loungers 2 chairs and small table. Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Right above the middle of Eden. Balcony Overhang?: no. Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: Very quiet. Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Not internal, outside to left only. Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: PROS: Fantastic location with no "passing traffic". Long walk to elevator/stairs so no guilt about that extra cannoli in Tuscan for sweets;) Wake view gives a calming visual, and white noise. Minimal noise heard from Eden below, and that's VERY minimal, at least on our cruise as all entertainment finished at 11.15 pm in Eden. CONS: Slight soot on balcony...pool towels used to cover loungers and chairs. Just check in the morning before resting arms on the railing. Would You Book It Again?: Already have:) 🙂 Edited March 10 by lara h Ship name & date sailed 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kittybay13 Posted March 18 #271 Share Posted March 18 Date of Cruise: October 30, 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 12268 - starboard side (moved to 12267 - portside - review posted for it as well below) Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: C2 - Concierge Cabin Location: Aft Bed Position: By Wardrobe Balcony Type: Infinite Veranda Balcony/Window Size: Standard IV Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Overhang from cantilevered deck above blocks views up (can't see sky, can only look down) Balcony Overhang?: Yes, Overhang from cantilevered deck above blocks views up (can't see sky, can only look down) Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: Yes. Cabin creaked, popped, squealed and whistled so loudly we just could not sleep. In addition, cabin is directly under the service area for the Oceanview. Service carts are brought here where staff bang them into the walls. Noise started at 4AM when apparently set up for buffet begins. Noise continued through the entire morning and into early afternoon. Between the walls and ceiling and IV balcony and this "kitchen" noise, we were just miserable without sleep. Requested a cabin change to 11267 - same cabin noises plus more (see review) Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: Noise. Do not book. With earplugs I still could not tolerate the noise enough to sleep. Requested a room change. Had to wait a few days to get a new room -- I suspect someone else left the room we were moved to. The Beyond has a big problem with noise. Other people who were in cabins 12276 and 12278 were also overwhelmed with how loud it was all night and all day. Would You Book It Again?: I will not sail on the Beyond ever again Photos or Photo Links: 399432159_24080323014944528_667893179869247766_n.mp4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kittybay13 Posted March 18 #272 Share Posted March 18 Date of Cruise: October 30, 2023 Ship: Beyond Cabin #: 12267 - portside (After moving from 12268 see above) Deck #: 12 Cabin Category: C2 - Concierge Cabin Location: Aft Bed Position: By Wardrobe Balcony Type: Infinite Veranda Balcony/Window Size: Standard IV Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Overhang from cantilevered deck above blocks views up (can't see sky, can only look down) Balcony Overhang?: Yes, Overhang from cantilevered deck above blocks views up (can't see sky, can only look down) Magic Carpet Issues?: No Noise Issues?: Yes. We moved to this cabin after having noise in the first cabin (12268). Noise was not a lot better. We thought it might be an improvement since there was cabin noise AND kitchen noise in 12268. But this cabin creaked, popped, squealed and whistled so loudly we just could not sleep as well. Additionally, this cabin is farther forward under the Oceanview. Not sure who was thinking having stools in the buffet would be good. They are on tiles, not carpet. Every time someone moves them, they scrape across the floor. This noise starts with cleaning at 4AM and continues through the morning. We were just miserable without sleep. Since there were no available cabins to move to, we just dealt with it. Wind Issues?: No Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: Noise. It seems most of the aft balcony cabins on Deck 12 suffer from both the cabin noises and the Oceanview noises. Do not book. Would You Book It Again?: I will not sail on the Beyond ever again Photos or Photo Links: 399432159_24080323014944528_667893179869247766_n.mp4 20231105_105604.mp4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
journeymore Posted March 20 #273 Share Posted March 20 Date of Cruise: January 25, 2024 Ship: Edge Cabin #: 6140 Deck #: 6 Cabin Category: Solo IV Cabin Location: Forward Bed Position: Balcony Balcony Type: IV Balcony/Window Size: Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: Balcony Overhang?: Magic Carpet Issues?: Noise Issues?: Wind Issues?: Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No Suite Details: Advantages/Problems/Comments: No storage space/drawers Would You Book It Again?: Yes Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yurita Posted March 20 #274 Share Posted March 20 Cruise: 3/1/2024 Ship: Apex Cabin #: 10249 Aqua class Deck #: 10 Cabin Location: Mid-Aft Balcony Type: Infinite Balcony Size: Standard Aqua Balcony Obstruction: None Balcony Overhang?: no Magic Carpet Issues?: did not hear Noise Issues?: Yes. Very loud metal dragging noise from midnight to 5am. Also sounds similar to multiple heavy duty drawers closing one after another. Impossible to sleep. Met our neighbors from 11249 during a shore excursion. Same complaint . Very loud cabins at night. Noise reported to Front Desk and it did get better the last couple of nights. They sent security a couple of times to check noise status. Wind Issues?: no Connecting Cabin? No Suite Details: Bed by bathroom . Sofa by Balcony. Advantages/Problems/Comments: Noisy at night. Would not consider again due to noise Would You Book It Again?: no, especially being light sleepers. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Wedgeh Posted March 22 #275 Share Posted March 22 Date of Cruise: 10/3/2024 Ship: Ascent Cabin #: 3161 Deck #: 3 Cabin Category: Inside Cabin Location: Port side Bed Position: N/A Balcony Type: N/A Balcony/Window Size: N/A Balcony/Window View/Obstruction: N/A Balcony Overhang?: N/A Magic Carpet Issues?: N/A Noise Issues?: Severe - prompting me to make this review. We experienced loud sounds which we guessed were trolleys being moved in the corridor which is behind the room leading from the martini bar. Also some loud plumbing noise which we initially guessed was toilets flushing, but wasn't sure. Wind Issues?: N/A Connecting Cabin? Where Does it Connect?: No Suite Details: N/A Advantages/Problems/Comments: The room was pretty well located. Would You Book It Again?: No Photos or Photo Links: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now