milepig Posted June 21 #1 Share Posted June 21 Boarding in Vancouver was easy maybe 20 minutes, but we were the only ship that day. Silversea has boarding times stated but we arrived about 12:30 and were processed right through. At boarding, La Terrazza was a disaster. Full of people who clearly had never cruised before, mass confusion, and staff starting something and not finishing. Laughably tiny desserts and a deplenished buffet at 2:00 which was when boarding officially commenced. Horrible first impression . Now Altantude is our go to and it’s like oasis. Our butler was horrible, and offered essentially no service. We now have a new one after complaining and so far good, he’s on the spot and very helpful. Indochine is great, as is Atlantis. Kaiser was worth the supplement, the grill is so so. Apparently they no longer call it Hot Rocks. It would be nice to know they are twinned with spacconapoli and bring stuff back and worth. We had a very troubled dinner at La Terra’s and dont plan on going back. We’ve already booked our next cruise. any typos are due to my fat fingers 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare DavyWavey70 Posted June 21 #2 Share Posted June 21 I’m sorry to hear of your experience so far. Could you maybe offer a little more detail on why your Butler was horrible, the troubled dinner in la Terraza etc? I Hope things improve from here on in. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bullswood Posted June 21 #3 Share Posted June 21 1 hour ago, DavyWavey70 said: I Hope things improve from here on in. Considering that Silver Muse boarded at Seward today and is heading south, I assume this isn't the current cruise. Interesting variety of restaurant names though! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare Port Power Posted June 21 #4 Share Posted June 21 So this is a sort of a review of a cruise just completed? I agree with @DavyWavey70, some more details of the negative comments would be helpful. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
agape01 Posted June 21 #5 Share Posted June 21 2 hours ago, milepig said: Kaiser was worth the supplement, Would like to ask whether it be possible to reorder dishes if it was good? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rojaan19 Posted June 21 #6 Share Posted June 21 4 hours ago, milepig said: Boarding in Vancouver was easy maybe 20 minutes, but we were the only ship that day. Indochine is great, as is Atlantis. Kaiser was worth the supplement, the grill is so so. Apparently they no longer call it Hot Rocks. any typos are due to my fat fingers Atlantis - I pressume you mean Atlantide and Kaiser for Kaiseki. We also like Indochine. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
lincslady Posted June 21 #7 Share Posted June 21 The review does read a lot like others which are never followed up by their OP. There can be various reasons for this, but it leaves everyone wanting more information, so hope it will be forthcoming. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RetiredandTravel Posted June 21 #8 Share Posted June 21 Sounds like a rough start. Luck of the draw I guess, our bitler was awesome. I'd say look him up but his contract was ending and he was going home to see his wife & kids. We didn't go to La T for lunch not a fan of buffets. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
dawntrdr Posted June 21 #9 Share Posted June 21 I pretty much write off a review full of negative comments when it ends with "We've already booked our next cruise." 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Will Work for Tiramisu Posted June 21 #10 Share Posted June 21 We got off the Muse in Seward yesterday. As I said earlier, staff on the boat were as nice as can be, to a man or woman. Mostly Philippine, but other countries noted - various African, Indian, Chinese. Butler was nice as could be, couldn't do enough for us. Lots of flowers, but not on dining tables. A few cases where if someone had wrong answer, I could go elsewhere and get right answer - it is a human organization, after all. Had lovely dinner with head of Shore Concierge and his wife, who is head of HR. Very interesting chat with her about getting all the people needed with technical licenses and training to operate all the many ship functions, and providing ongoing training. Able bodied seamen are still a thing - handling the lines, painting, doing endless ship board duties. Food mostly OK, but we're spoiled from home cooking & local Oregon restaurants. We didn't starve. Everyone eager to top off your wineglass. Ship in good shape, suite immaculate. We tipped the room stewart everyday, and the butler twice a week, as well as anyone handing us lattes or such. Visited Arts Cafe every morning for latte & snacks for DW. We'd go back for the right itinerary - but I'd probably top out after 2-3 weeks, needing more variety in dining. Ironically, rather than "pay extra" options with lots of hype, I'd rather see them up the game on basic free food - more variety, a few options for people that don't require or prefer bland food; unleash the tonic chefs! But generally, we got our value, and would return. 7 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 21 Author #11 Share Posted June 21 (edited) 12 hours ago, DavyWavey70 said: I’m sorry to hear of your experience so far. Could you maybe offer a little more detail on why your Butler was horrible, the troubled dinner in la Terraza etc? I Hope things improve from here on in. Sure. He scribbled lots of notes, left and not much was accomplished. Didn’t lay eyes on him for days. We have a new butler for leg 2 and he has been amazing. Things that were impossible are no longer a problem. This is how it should be. Edited June 21 by milepig 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 21 Author #12 Share Posted June 21 8 hours ago, rojaan19 said: Atlantis - I pressume you mean Atlantide and Kaiser for Kaiseki. We also like Indochine. Indochine, which my phone can’t spell!, is great. Good spice level, and they can make it spicier, one night the short rib was quite fatty, but the pho made up for it. The noodle side as amazing. Kaiseki was also good, but lacked a certain flair that similar concepts have, the staff didn’t seem to be having fun. But great food. Go early if you want to sit at the counter, it fills up fast. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Texas Tillie Posted June 21 #13 Share Posted June 21 50 minutes ago, Will Work for Tiramisu said: We got off the Muse in Seward yesterday. As I said earlier, staff on the boat were as nice as can be, to a man or woman. Mostly Philippine, but other countries noted - various African, Indian, Chinese. Butler was nice as could be, couldn't do enough for us. Lots of flowers, but not on dining tables. A few cases where if someone had wrong answer, I could go elsewhere and get right answer - it is a human organization, after all. Had lovely dinner with head of Shore Concierge and his wife, who is head of HR. Very interesting chat with her about getting all the people needed with technical licenses and training to operate all the many ship functions, and providing ongoing training. Able bodied seamen are still a thing - handling the lines, painting, doing endless ship board duties. Food mostly OK, but we're spoiled from home cooking & local Oregon restaurants. We didn't starve. Everyone eager to top off your wineglass. Ship in good shape, suite immaculate. We tipped the room stewart everyday, and the butler twice a week, as well as anyone handing us lattes or such. Visited Arts Cafe every morning for latte & snacks for DW. We'd go back for the right itinerary - but I'd probably top out after 2-3 weeks, needing more variety in dining. Ironically, rather than "pay extra" options with lots of hype, I'd rather see them up the game on basic free food - more variety, a few options for people that don't require or prefer bland food; unleash the tonic chefs! But generally, we got our value, and would return. Always wonder if the service is the same for someone who is known to keep passing out tips vs those who take the cruise line at its word that gratuities are included? 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 21 Author #14 Share Posted June 21 12 minutes ago, Texas Tillie said: Always wonder if the service is the same for someone who is known to keep passing out tips vs those who take the cruise line at its word that gratuities are included? I had the same thought. The post made it sound like cash was falling out of his pockets. Our approach is to something the last day for those were great. 7 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bullswood Posted June 22 #15 Share Posted June 22 (edited) 8 hours ago, milepig said: I had the same thought. The post made it sound like cash was falling out of his pockets. Our approach is to something the last day for those were great. WWFT clearly wants us all to know how generous he is. From his report in another thread on the same cruise: "Of course, I decided to tip from day one this time, thinking better than wait for end, and hand out dollar coins to every barista and wine-refiller and plate clearer, to say nothing of larger denominations to room steward & butler every couple days, also to bartenders and waitstaff. Much bowing and scraping ensues, and we almost have to beat the butler off with a stick." Each to their own, I suppose but to me (as a non-U.S.traveller) this seems gross behaviour. Do you get a kick out of "bowing and scraping" and having to "beat the butler off with a stick"? IMHO you seem to treat the staff as if you're feeding ducks in the park. Edited June 22 by Bullswood 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 22 Author #16 Share Posted June 22 My FIL told us to travel to Europe with dollar bills since “they all love dollars”!! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare DavyWavey70 Posted June 22 #17 Share Posted June 22 1 hour ago, Bullswood said: WWFT clearly wants us all to know how generous he is. From his report in another thread on the same cruise: "Of course, I decided to tip from day one this time, thinking better than wait for end, and hand out dollar coins to every barista and wine-refiller and plate clearer, to say nothing of larger denominations to room steward & butler every couple days, also to bartenders and waitstaff. Much bowing and scraping ensues, and we almost have to beat the butler off with a stick." Each to their own, I suppose but to me (as a non-U.S.traveller) this seems gross behaviour. Do you get a kick out of "bowing and scraping" and having to "beat the butler off with a stick"? IMHO you seem to treat the staff as if you're feeding ducks in the park. Please don’t disparage WWFT. Some of us have leaky pockets, some of us don’t. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare Host Jazzbeau Posted June 22 #18 Share Posted June 22 As an American, I find it creepy. 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MuseCruiser Posted June 22 #19 Share Posted June 22 8 hours ago, Host Jazzbeau said: As an American, I find it creepy. Same here. Gross behavior. 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare Tothesunset Posted June 22 #20 Share Posted June 22 At least we have a reference point for where tipping becomes bribery. 4 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 22 Author #21 Share Posted June 22 3 hours ago, MuseCruiser said: Same here. Gross behavior. I missed the part about dollar COINS. Make it hard to use! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Texas Tillie Posted June 22 #22 Share Posted June 22 1 hour ago, milepig said: 4 hours ago, MuseCruiser said: Same here. Gross behavior. I missed the part about dollar COINS. Make it hard to use! Went back and checked if they were European where everything that is under 5 Euros, Pounds, etc. is coin and those coins are used commonly there. No, it's an American and those dollar coins are VERY difficult to use. 😮🙄😏 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
milepig Posted June 22 Author #23 Share Posted June 22 50 minutes ago, Texas Tillie said: Went back and checked if they were European where everything that is under 5 Euros, Pounds, etc. is coin and those coins are used commonly there. No, it's an American and those dollar coins are VERY difficult to use. 😮🙄😏 The only place I’ve found when I stuck with them are vending machines. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
pavementends Posted June 22 #24 Share Posted June 22 (edited) On 6/21/2024 at 8:43 AM, Texas Tillie said: Always wonder if the service is the same for someone who is known to keep passing out tips vs those who take the cruise line at its word that gratuities are included? Last year now I experienced perfectly fine service without tipping. Maybe I'm naive but take the statement that gratuities are included to mean...that gratuities are included. Foolish, I know. We don't want or need much from our butler. Who did cheerfully provide the small number of things we asked for. I'm happy to let him have time to cater to those who have continual needs. If tipping means that he would be continually bothering us asking for stuff to do I would consider that a negative. Edited June 22 by pavementends Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Emdee Posted June 22 #25 Share Posted June 22 I think people who are not used to having staff tip “ to keep them on their toes”. The rest of us offer gracious thanks or a small consideration as thanks. 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now