Need help quick! Cruise decision for April

[Sadie cruiser]

I am considering these 2 cruises: Which has the best itinerary? 2 adults and a teen. I have to book in the next 2 days. Thanks!:)

 

1. FOS - 4/13-4/20 - Labadee, Cozumel, Grand Cayman, Falmouth

2. IOS - 4/12-4/20 - Labadee, St. Maarten, San Juan, St. Kitts

[overthehillcruiser]

My vote is for # 2..

[rummenroman]

I would also vote number 2.

[Clarea]

I'd also take Indy, for the extra day, eastern itinerary, and no tendering.

[winjos]

Been on both and we really liked the Eastern itinerary better. In fact, we are going on IOS for Thanksgiving. Loving the extra day too.

[Sadie cruiser]

True about the extra day.:) I didn't even think to ask about the tendering. Good point! DreamWorks is not on the Indy ...right? My decision is leaning towards the Indy. Oh! I forgot to mention that the Indy is $500.00 cheaper for an inside room than FOS. Yesterday, it was a $1000.00 cheaper than FOS and I didn't book it fast enough. What was I thinking?

[Clarea]

True about the extra day.:) I didn't even think to ask about the tendering. Good point! DreamWorks is not on the Indy ...right? My decision is leaning towards the Indy. Oh! I forgot to mention that the Indy is $500.00 cheaper for an inside room than FOS. Yesterday, it was a $1000.00 cheaper than FOS and I didn't book it fast enough. What was I thinking?

No Dreamworks on Indy.

[DonnaK]

I would also book Indy. Less expensive, extra day, and all the ports are good ones.