Celebrity Silhouette or R.C. Independence of the Seas?

[liv2cruise4ever]

Which would you choose. 7 days E. Car. on Celebrity or 8 days R. C. Independence of the Seas. Have not cruised either cruise line. We like to dine at our own leisure. It's been awhile since I've been on the boards! Thank you all in advance. :cool:

[JanineM]

It depends on what you want to do onboard the ship. Celebrity is going to be more subdued - more laid back activities. Both ships offer dine-anytime options. Both ships are beautiful.

 

For me, it would come down to the itinerary and how much 'action' wanted on the ship. We prefer Celebrity because we're not into the pool games or the flowrider or any of those activities. We kindof like a bit quieter experience.

[liv2cruise4ever]

I like the more subdued for sure. Pool games....no thanks...LOL I'm leaning on Celebrity. Thank you!