Ike Witt vs. Rumbaba

[Newlyweds28]

I know there are numerous posts on both Rumbaba and Ike Witt. Could anyone tell me what the differences between these two day sails are?

 

I contacted both Captain Pat (Ike Witt) and Captain Bobby (Rumbaba). When I spoke with Captain Pat, he seemed more confident that he could give us the best day of our trip. I didn't get that same impression from Captain Bobby. I more or less got the impression that he would like our business, but that he was busy.

 

However, is the lunch aboard Rumbaba much better than the lunch aboard Ike Witt? What are the other differences? Who would YOU recommend?

 

Thank you for your time!