Half Moon Cay or Coco Cay?

[Lyncoya]

I'm trying to decide....which do you think is better? Right now, based on price, RCI is winning. I've been on 3 cruises with Carnival. I feel like a traitor.

[TITISSA]

I've been to both and Half Moon Cay is much better than Coco Cay.

[BARBARA J.W.]

I've been to both and Half Moon Cay is much better than Coco Cay.

 

I agree Half Moon Cay.........

[Starfire_rules]

In the dictionary it should read:

Paradise; n, Half Moon Cay

[PeskyKid]

Can't believe RCI is cheaper. Both private Islands are great. Price is always the main factor when we decide. Carnival is hard to beat for what you get.

[ABcruisers]

Hands down Half Moon Cay!!! I was there a couple of years ago and I have wanted to go back ever since. I have been to both Cococay and Half Moon and of course they are both beautiful but Half Moon is right out of a magazine. The beaches are powdery sand that extends far into the water so there is no sea weed or rocks. The bar is right on the beach so you can hear the live music all along the beach. All in all it is the perfect idyllic beach.

[mom2girls]

I'm happy everyone is saying that Half Moon Cay is better! :) I've been to both Labadee and CocoCay, and I thought I was in paradise both times. I'm really looking forward to Half Moon Cay in June.

[ABcruisers]

I know how you feel, my first private island was Labadee and I was in love but then we went to Cococay I was a little disappointed it was a little too rocky and sea weedy for me:o So when we booked the Triumph and it was going to Half Moon Cay I wasn't expecting much...I was wrong out of the three it is the best. You will love it:D

[Lyncoya]

Believe it or not...a 4 nighter on RCI is going for 349 for an OV pp. I've done all of the short Carnival Cruises...i'm kind of sick of the itineraries. I'd like to try the Destiny, but it's a little to expensive for our tastes at the moment. (we're looking at going in May) I would LOVE to see HMC *sigh*

[777mjrseb]

I have never visited the other island as I have only done CC. I will say when I stepped off the ship in Half Moon I thought it was unreal. Looked like a clear swimming pool to me! The water was amazing. :D

[cruising_kelly]

I've done both as well and have to admit.. I thought Half Moon Cay was much nicer!!! It is simply paradise!

[Typhoon1]

I have mentioned this in the past, is if it sound redundant, it is.

 

HMC is consistently mentioned as "The Best" private island in the cruise industry publications.

 

Having been to Princess Cays, I can see why.