Personal opinion here only…. Others will tell you none of this matters.
I’ve sailed the Pride three times and it’s one of my favorite ships. But….I personally am not booking any more Carnival sailings for now after a recent Sunshine sailing, albeit a short one, that made me actually question safety. I’ve also sailed NCL and like the experience, but they’ve lost their minds with pricing.
The older Carnival ships have really been let go unfortunately. We experienced broken elevators to our floor (in an accessible cabin so stairs not an option), sewage in the hallway that maintenance tried to fix and couldn’t, sewage backing up through the shower drain in our bathroom, broken furniture all over the ship, rust, broken railings, broken windows, holes in the deck…it’s was shocking after 20 Carnival trips and knowing the ship I was on had just been in dry dock a couple months earlier. What were we not seeing behind the scenes that wasn’t maintained if this is what the customers saw? I sadly wasn’t surprised when news of the Freedom fire and Magic fumes issue (with payoff offers to not sue) hit not long after we sailed.
Food and service were not good and the crew was working crazy long days due to the staffing issues. They were trying…and were tired, worn out, and many stated they would not renew contracts. MDR food was the worst in 24 cruises. Music was one terrible band and one even worse solo guitarist with very few daytime activities anymore, either.
You’ll have a totally different crowd in Europe of course, but we also noticed a lack of security at the deck parties, nightclub, etc… had something gone south….and it did outside our cabin the last night…. there was not enough security to handle it.
My next cruise is likely MSC or Celebrity. Both are far cheaper than Carnival right now, too. All lines have staff and supply chain issues right now, but I was shocked by the badly deteriorated ship. Security was I’ll equipped to handle the incident outside our cabin at 3am and either would not or could not remove the persons involved. The screaming and threats went on for over an hour with security present and we drove 7 hours home the next day on no sleep.
Just my two cents as a once loyal Carnival cruiser who loved the experience. I’ll give them a couple years to work the kinks out and likely only consider newer ships with them now, though.