So happy to have found this thread!
We will be in the Haven in October and had no idea what a Butler could bring to the cruise.
We are using cruise credit from March, 2020 - the month we all began to realize just how much our world would changed. We would have been in Tahiti and Hawaii then, now we will be in Alaska. Same ocean, significantly different trip.
I found all of your comments and suggestions very helpful. We don't think of ourselves as being Butler types but we will see how it goes!