Took my wife, 3 year old daughter, mother-in-law, and two besties (who are Celebrity Elite, first time on Royal) in 3 consecutive balcony cabins (2 of which connected). We sailed on Allure earlier this year, and many years ago we did a 4 night out of LA on Monarch, so this was our 3rd Royal cruise. Have also sailed Celebrity and Disney once each in past years. Wanted to see if Navigator would be a good lower-price option for us in the future without having to fly to Florida and this sailing was pretty cheap when I booked it. CC board was instrumental in my research, so wanted to leave my thoughts here for anyone who cares!
GOOD:
The iSkate ice show is INSANE, the skaters INCREDIBLE. Wife was glad we came just for this. Makes the one on the Allure look quite sad in comparison
Stateroom attendant, Anne, was awesome. Best we've ever had
Rooms felt big and new. We were in 1832-1834-1836 on deck 12, forward. These rooms were added during the amplification in 2019. Loved being up high. Showers were hot with perfect pressure
MDR was overall, excellent. We skipped night 3 to do Chops as a date night, and the rest of our party found that to be the worst night by far in the MDR. MIL ordered the Chops filet on the final night and she really enjoyed, but it didn't really seem to resemble the cuts we had had the night before in Chops
Escape room was fun, but not necessarily worth $20 a person IMO. It was pretty difficult and our room of 10+ people didn't finish by the buzzer but we were so close the attendant let us complete it anyway. Also seems like an odd activity for a ship since so many people are repeat cruisers - this is not a repeatable activity, but I suppose its footprint is extremely small
Windjammer breakfast and lunch was consistently good, but often was a real chore to find a table. Having two uninspiring ports (Catalina, Ensenada) definitely contributed to it being more crowded on port days. Felt bigger than the WJ on the Allure, which we avoided like the plague after trying once since there was always a huge line
Jamie's Italian for lunch was an excellent value at $15.99 per person; truffle pasta was really great as was everything else we tried. We did this on embarkation day at noon right after boarding, which was perfect. We got to enjoy a leisurely, fantastic meal while outside in the WJ what appeared to be thousands of people were fighting for food and seats
Main stage singers and dancers were super talented
The Bamboo Room is easily the best bar onboard. Bartender Caleb knows what's up
Ship orchestra and Frequency band were top-notch
The Blaster water slide was surprisingly fun and we did it twice even though it was (to our California blood) freezing outside
Thought the Christmas decorations onboard were really elegant and beautiful
MIL loved the food and ate what for her is a ton of food, which we were excited about since at home she basically eats one egg, a piece of bread and some air each day
MIDDLING:
Adventure Ocean for the 3 year old. She was very excited to go for the first time, but the club itself was pretty bare, and the only playspace was a small rock climbing wall that's beyond her ability at this age. Ship also has no playground area or playground-esque equipment (Allure had that on the Boardwalk), so on cold days the only entertaining option for a kid her age was the club. The counselors couldn't have been nicer and she had fun going, but it was just basic crafts and some toys for them to play with. Would easily become boring over a longer trip. When we were on Allure she was still 2, so I didn't get to check out AO there but now I'm curious to see if it's bigger and more interesting
Activity scheduling was not great, IMO. Lots and lots of trivia sessions. One night the only options for dancing after 9PM was the silent disco, which we realize many people enjoy, but we do not
Windjammer desserts are always a vast variety every day, and they're mostly mid to bad. There was always something good enough (and the rum balls/cream cheese balls were fab), but we found this on Allure too. The shipwide desserts - WJ, Park/Promenade Cafes, were all kind of odd and just not good. This is really a positive because it's hard enough to not gain weight on a cruise ship
After having a pretty poor experience with Chops on Allure, we tried it again here for our date night sans kid since we're not huge on seafood or sushi. It was better than it had been on Allure in the spring, but the steak still wasn't *great* - I don't know. I've had many better filets at Walt Disney World than I've had at either of my Chops experiences. The menu is also extremely basic. Would love to see a little more adventure in the options. On Allure we loved 150 Central Park, and if I had had that option here we would have gladly taken it again. So Chops was good, not great, and IMO not worth $50 per person for the privilege
BAD:
Not RC's fault obviously, but it was too cold. Won't ever sail this time of year out of LA again unless they start heating the pools, which I feel like they could easily do and make a lot of people happy!
Loudspeaker on our balcony (1834) playing muzak at all hours of the day. Don't recall having one of these on our Allure balcony and it *really* sucks since I love to just chill on the balcony and don't necessarily need Maroon 5 songs to help me do it
The port is a disorganized mess. Getting on the ship and getting off was stressful and messy, with people everywhere and very little direction. A wheelchair mixup between the check in folks and the boarding folks resulted in a lot of upset people being told they'd need to wait an hour to be taken on the ship if they needed to be wheeled
We saw one production show, Ballroom Fever, and it was so ghastly we couldn't finish it. Stupefying choice after stupefying choice for costumes, scenery, staging, songs/arrangements. The cast was phenomenal, and I really wish they had better material to showcase them. We skipped the Showgirl show as a result
I know this is discussed all the time, but the coffee card sucks and I should have looked into it before buying it. We never get one-shot coffee drinks, so the card's value plummeted immediately. Lesson learned!
Casino smoke smell permeated into the middle of the Promenade from the stairwell leading down to it
Our Celebrity Elite besties were disappointed that the spa had no thermal suite option, no spa cafe, and the solarium wasn't covered (things they knew going in of course, but found it impacted their enjoyment more than they expected)
All things considered it was a fun cruise, but I don't think we would be willing to book Navigator again until our daughter is older. We don't have the budget to cruise a lot but would like to do one a year going forward, and for now I think Disney will be a better fit (despite the wide gap in pricing). I'm always checking Oasis class pricing though - I'm sure we'll get back on one of those within the next few years. We found we were really missing some of the things Allure had that Navigator didn't.