Hi, just booked my second HAL cruise and had the exact same doubts as you @Annjem. Decided the Have it alle rate wasn't worth it with our glas of wine, cappuccino and a soda and pay per drink and excursion individually.
After booking and login found out about the Have it Alle offer at reduced rate $50 offer. Already halved. Now - pricewise - it is just under / above break even for us.
To throw everything into the mix... my question:
If i prepurchase the have it all will the amount count to the mariner points? Or is that only expenses made on board the ship? And if so - does anybody know if it is possible to book the have it all on board and against which price?
Thank you!