This is my favorite thread ... please keep the discourse flowing (even those I vehemently disagree with) 🙂
As many have mentioned, it's a value proposition. For me, as someone going on a spring break Caribbean cruise in March, I bought passes for my wife and I even though our 10-year old won't be able to gain access ... because I am highly confident the pool deck will be packed and super loud, chairs hard to find, and the bar constantly backed up. A relaxed place in the sun or shade with a comfortable chair, a great view, and easily accessible drinks makes the upgrade worth it to me. My wife doesn't know I bought the passes yet so I can't wait to find out if she agrees with me. I would use it early morning, during the day, and before dinner, particularly if my 10-year old is hanging out in the kids club.