We too have been a little nervous about sailing on Princess and the Island. Having sailed on several other lines don't really know what to expect and all the negative comments had worried us.
However, posts like these have helped make us feel better. This cruise just fits perfectly what we were looking for after having not been able to cruise for over 2 1/2 years.
I actually think this sounds more like the kind of ship we initially sailed on and fell in love with cruising back in 1999.
Can't wait till next month to get back on the ocean.