Need an opinion: Valor or Legend?

[SJChaput]

My wife and I are looking into a cruise with another couple and they want to go on the Valor because its less expensive and I am partial to the Legend as I spent my honeymoon on that ship.

 

Cost and sentimental value aside which ship would you rather go on?

Which is the nicer ship (if such a distinction can be made)

 

Maybe if you're feeling generous maybe some pros and cons.

 

Any help would be appreciated.

 

Thanks.

[S.S.Oceanlover]

My wife and I are looking into a cruise with another couple and they want to go on the Valor because its less expensive and I am partial to the Legend as I spent my honeymoon on that ship.

 

Cost and sentimental value aside which ship would you rather go on?

Which is the nicer ship (if such a distinction can be made)

 

Maybe if you're feeling generous maybe some pros and cons.

 

Any help would be appreciated.

 

Thanks.

 

I'd book Valor just for the simple fact it has the Seaside theater. I love laying out at night watching the movies.:)

 

Bill

[shannonrt3]

Not sure if this helps or not, but I just booked the Legend for Dec 11 because my Travel agent said it was dry docked for refurbishing in February and she recommended it.

[marshhawk]

Book both. Seriously, a cruise is an investment, if you aren't both on the same page, one of you will not be happy going. Perhaps if you looked at itineraries instead of ships it might help. That said, I honeymooned on the Legend and just booked it again. But I only have to keep my DH happy.;)