New to HAL

[cruz chic]

I don't think the intent of most posters who offer differing experiences is to call the OP a liar but rather to show that whatever the problem was is not a systemic problem in their experience.:cool:

 

Differing opinions are one thing. There are 3 posters that were VERY nasty to me after I reported experiences on my cruise on the Westy that were less than positive. There is no need to be that way. There were posters on the Z last year that had bad experiences with the a/c and toilets that also got attacked when they reported that. There is not reason to do that.

[sail7seas]

We sailed on the Eurodam in Jan 2012. You can read my review, which touched on some of the problems, here: http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberreviews/memberreview.cfm?EntryID=96447.

 

It was this cruise in which we swore we would never book another Neptune suite again.

 

Thanks for providing the link to your review.

Wow, you certainly did have a bad experience on Eurodam. Very sorry to read all that went wrong. I grateful our experiences on five cruises on that ship were far more positive. Everyone should have a good experience.

 

[mamaofami]

St. Marten , especially the French side, is a much nicer island than St. Thomas. All this talk of a Caribbean cruise makes me tempted to look into booking for next winter.