3-night Bahamas: RCL Majesty or Norwegian Sky?

[JerseyBird]

Dear Board,

 

Hubby and I are trying to take a mini vacation on Oct 30th, only these RCL Majesty and Norwegian Sky fit our schedule. I know they are similar, in the same calibers, can you please still voice your opinions as which is a better choice in terms of:

 

1. Which boat is in a better shape?

2. Which food is slightly better?

3. RCL goes to Cococay, Norwegian goes to Great Stirrup Cay

Which island has a better beach? Better for snorkeling?

 

Thank you very much for your input!

 

JerseyBird

[bostonbill]

IN my Mind only!!!

 

Sky is newer and has balconies....

 

I find RCL and NCL food to be very similar..

 

Coco Cay and Great Stirrup Cay are right next to each other(less than a mile apart)

 

I just picked the Majesty based on a better deal $$$.....

 

I don't think you'd go wrong with either

[runner15km]

Maybe this info will sway you. :D

http://www.ncl.com/terms/sky-inclusive-beverage

[tggs726]

Sky is newer and has UBP promotion for 2015 and becomes all inclusive 2016. That alone would sway me towards the Sky.

 

Outside of that its a pretty similar product.

 

-Matt