Edge class - which cabin would you choose?

[DonnaK]

My choices on an Edge class ship are:

 

Infinity balcony = I selected a cabin in the location of my choice

or

Concierge class guarantee

 

The price is the same.

 

Which would you choose?

[retird]

I would choose location of my choice.   

[doghog]

5 minutes ago, DonnaK said:

My choices on an Edge class ship are:

 

Infinity balcony = I selected a cabin in the location of my choice

or

Concierge class guarantee

 

The price is the same.

 

Which would you choose?

Based on the two choices, IV. We prefer to pick our own stateroom, floor and location. We don't do guarantees. 

[deliver42]

It's still and IV for concierge, not a deal.

[wineoclock]

Neither. I’d want a proper balcony. So I’d probably book a different class of ship or another line if no SV or suites at a decent price. 

[lv2cruisgrl]

I would pick my own balcony. You never know what or where they will put you on a guarantee.