Gibbs Cay w/ Stingrays or Guana Hop on Hop off with children?

[Swice]

Trying to decide between the two ...

 

We have two boys ages 6 and 4 (who thinks he's 10!).

 

On Holland America

[twinkletoes4445]

We did the bus tour, and you are able to get off and walk around, so at least your kids wouldn't be stuck on a bus for a long time. I'm trying to think what my kids would have liked at that age, and I think they probably would have been good with either.

 

I'm not familar with the stingray excursion in GT, so I don't know how deep the water is...and that might make a difference.

[Swice]

We appreciate the reply.

[twinkletoes4445]

Whatever you end up doing, have a great time. :)

[PACURN]

I have two boys and they would much rather spend time in the water. We always plan some type of snorkeling activity in at least one port. It looks like this will be the one for us. They willing sightsee with me but would really rather be in the water.