If not NCL - RCCL or Carnival?

[halos]

Since you're from New York, why not think about the Miracle which is doing an 8-night from NY.

 

I agree, if you're from NY, sail out of NY!!

My favorite cruise to date was on the Miracle!

I haven't sailed RCI (YET!!) But I have sailed Carnival 4 times and have never been disappointed.

[mbisson]

I think I should go on Carnival for the first one, which ship. want one with the best of best and everything. I never thought cruising would be so hard. Sorry for all the trouble.

 

Since you've ruled out NCL, I'd be asking on the Carnival board and not this one.

[maurick]

If not NCL, RCCL out of Bayonne.

[honeydog714]

Royal hands down, plus they have some great sales going on right now, next to Disney they are our favorite- much nicer than carnival in my opinion

[ce2000]

Both Carnival and RCCL make you eat at either 6PM or 8PM totally destroying any and all fun. :)

 

If you believe this, you need to try Carnival and RCCL sometime. You will be quite surprised at how much fun you can have.

[ce2000]

oops. duplicate post.