Always good to read a review from a first time cruiser.
We are not first time cruisers, but have booked the Alaska cruise on Koningsdam for next year, and it will be our first HAL experience.
My concern here is that the OP is comparing Club Orange to specialty dining, and from what I read, never actually dined in the MDR, so basically all dining was at an extra cost. I was hoping that there would be a comparison to the MDR in the review, as we have generally enjoyed MDRs on other cruise lines.