We had Rudi's on Celebration, that's the only ship we've ever had it, and have heard from a few that it wasn't quite as good as other ships. So for our first and only experience, we don't have anything to compare it to. We both enjoyed it though, we both got the Lobster Imperial or something like that, which was quite good. I will say though, we got dinner comped by the casino, and I'm not sure that I would pay the upcharge, at least on Celebration, since there were SO many other food options on that ship. And I just prefer steak. 😄 No complaints about the dinner though.