Always so weird how experiences can vary so much. We are on the sky right now for the first time and we have absolutely loved it.
Our whole experience this week has been excellent except for a little bit of madness at the port in Roatan (not enough infrastructure for two ships hitting the port at the same time).
But bars, service, etc have all been top notch and we like the styling and lay out of the ship better than any we’ve been on (all on DCL and Princess). We’ve also had no weather issues, so I do wonder if that had a snowball effect that led to OPs miserable experience.
Either way, I understand souring on a brand after a bad experience, and there are obviously lots of other great options so happy sailing wherever you head next. Take care.