Thank you everyone for your replies. When I say we're not big drinkers, I didn't mean to imply we're teetotalers. We love to have a Pina Colada by the pool, though perhaps not every day. But we'd probably order wine by the glass for both of us, definitely at dinner, and sometimes also at lunch. And sometimes the single poolside drink may become two.
The comment(s) about coffee, sparkling water, regular water are well taken. We like all the above. Still, it sounds like we wouldn't get value from a package, even at the current promo price. The one saving grace there is that we don't want to constantly think about what we're charging. Still, even with several beverage-related charges per person per day, it sounds like we're still better off going a la carte.
Someone commented on bringing wine. Yes, we're traveling 3000 miles to get there. So a bit unwieldy to pack it. But knowing there's a Total Wine nearby sounds great. We're fans of that store; and we love to buy a few medium-to-high-end wines to enjoy. Still, we'd probably enjoy those wines in the room or on deck, and still need to pay for wine by the glass at dinner.
Thanks again, everyone. We're not veteran (ocean) cruisers. It's been quite a while since our last ocean cruise, and the modern paradigm of extra cost for everything is kinda new to us.