I've only sailed Windstar once in 2016 (Windsurf) and thought the food was somewhere between excellent and outstanding. For some reason, we've not sailed Windstar since. (despite sailing approx. 16 times since on Oceania, (outstanding food) Silversea, (usually but not always excellent food) Viking Ocean ,(great ship but food just a little better than Denny's) Regent, (pretty good food but not memorable) HAL, (OK food) and Celebrity (very good to excellent depending on whether you have a suite or not).
We are looking forward to sailing with Windstar (likely on the Star Pride) soon so appreciate all the positive comments about the food.
Also remember the outstanding service and overall staff our only Windstar sailing. Hope it's still the same post COVID.