Smokeless Ashtray

[98Charlie]

Has anyone had experience with one of the ionic smokeless ashtrays?

 

We're going to get a smokeless before the next cruise but wonder about the ability of an ionic to keep the air clean.

 

TIA

 

Charlie

[Trevoli]

Is this for use in your cabin and/or on your balcony?

 

T

[98Charlie]

Is this for use in your cabin and/or on your balcony?

In the Cabin. We have read a number of times of people using a smokeless ashtray. So far they have been the kind with filters that have to be replaced. I have seen some ionic type advertised and would like some first hand feed back from someone who has used one.

 

Thanks

 

Charlie

[serene56]

M<y mom used this ashtray- she says she wasted her money.

Oh it works if you keep your cigerette by the thing. but if you stand away from it it doesnt work.

[Chele60]

Back when I smoked, I tried using one of these and it was a complete waste of money. It's somewhat okay as long as the cigarette is sitting directly in the ashtray. However, one must still pick up the cigarete and then exhale. And even exhaling directly at the ashtray (when one remembers to do this) doesn't really do all that much good.

 

I personally wouldn't waste the money. Just smoke on the balcony or in designated areas or quit altogether.