Mr Sancho's vs Passion Island with kids

[sara mom]

I've narrowed down my 2 choices for our Nov 30 stop in Cozumel...Mr Sancho's or Passion Island. It will be mom and 2 kids (7 and 5). Both have inflatable water toys that kids would love. Since I will be with 2 kids, an AI is not that important...I just want to have an awesome beach/fun/play day. I've read that Sancho's does not have snorkeling, but what about Passion Island? But then again, Sancho's has horse back riding for additional fee.

 

Looking for input and/or suggestions. THANKS!

[5waldos]

I will be following this post to see what people think. We chose Mr S because they offer a non drinking teen rate- a real plus since I have 3. Not an issue for you though.