Is Aqua Class worth upgrading to?

[lovemylab]

We had an Aqua Class stateroom last month on the Reflection and bottled water was replenished daily.

[LynnVB]

After our most recent experience in Aqua on the Summit, I would think twice about Aqua, at least on this ship. Blu was very nice and we enjoyed our dinner experience-breakfast was a different story. Our cabin was on deck 11. Nothing special, in fact our room-and those around us were very warm and downright uncomfortable temperature wise.

As for service, our travel companions stated they received much better service last May on Deck 8 in an inside cabin. We felt the same about our cruise last December in concierge. We had to ask for many things-second bathrobe, refills on shower gel, shampoo etc.

When they put in the movie screen on Deck 12-aqua on 11 will be awful. We were left with the feeling that that deck was the step-Aqua rooms.

We love the Persian Gardens, but have paid for the week without Aqua. We didn't notice anyone checking sea passes either, anyone could have walked in.

Our first experience in Aqua was on an S-class ship, much different. I think next time, we will go concierge, pay for specialty dining and Persian gardens with on board ship credits.