Honeymoon Beach on Water Island or St. John?

[Kyndal93]

I am trying to decide between two RC excursions.

 

1) Caribbean FastCat 2 island beach safari and snorkel. This goes to buck island to anchor off for snorkeling and then off to honeymoon beach at water island.

 

2) Half Day Champagne Sail to St. John. This goes to Honeymoon Beach on St. John for snorkeling and beach.

 

Which is a prettier beach and has better snorkeling?

 

Thanks

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

[Ms411]

Honeymoon Beach on St John.

[blue_water]

Have not snorkeled Buck Island so cannot compare to HB on STJ. But I wouldn't be excited about stopping at HB, Water Island because it gets so crowded there with the excursions like that one stopping in and other cruisers ferrying over from Crown.

 

The champagne cat is a very nice day though HB on STJ is a nice beach and sounds like a winner between the two!