Narrowed down to 3?

[Flintstone]

After pouring thru all the CL websites, I've narrowed our choices down to 3.
1. RCCL Serenade
2. NCL Star (read some bad reports)
3. NCL Sun
HAL is a little too $$ for what I want, Princess had no Skagway (a must for DH who has family roots there), Celebrity & Carnival had no Sun depart and I truly want an Aft Balcony. Of the above choices...can someone give me pros & Cons.

9/2000 Carnival Tropicale
12/2001 NCL Norway
9/2002 NCL Norway
10/2003 Disney Wonder
2005...Alaska

[Budget Queen]

Princess goes to Skagway??? Look at other factors, glacier- Glacier Bay would be my preference, ports, time in port, price, route.

[Flintstone]

I rechecked Princess yesterday....oops...Sapphire does dock in Skagway. The only difference I see with Princess is substituting Glacier Bay for Tracy Arms. But what would I know...having never been there. Am definately holding out for Princess rates since they are held in such high regard on these boards. Thank you BQ.

9/2000 Carnival Tropicale
12/2001 NCL Norway
9/2002 NCL Norway
10/2003 Disney Wonder
2005...Alaska