Cjonthesea Posted January 30 #3176 Share Posted January 30 (edited) SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 9405 DECK # (3-14) 9 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV IS-Single Interior LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Port Midship BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) N/A QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Usually BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) N/A BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) N/A WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) N/A SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) N/A PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) No noise from adjacent elevator. Music from Deck 3 via atrium gets loud during some sets, such as an entertainment staff show. Roomy enough for one. Adequate storage. Desk/chair. No couch. Annoyed by bedside lamp switch as you have to get out of bed to turn off. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS 1/25/24 Four of these cabins replaced Card Room. 9402 and 9405 do not face passageway. Edited January 30 by Cjonthesea Clarity 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mermen Posted February 15 #3177 Share Posted February 15 On 3/10/2023 at 7:09 PM, pd7277 said: @gerelmx No, it was updated on January 25, 2023 (less than two months ago) and covers every submission except for the last seven (7). If you open the spreadsheet from the link on the first page of this thread, you will see it says: @librarylady19 Carolyn did move on. I took her place in 2019. Converting all the cabin categories is on the to-do list. Maybe over the summer. Thank you for the time you spent running the spreadsheet. Thank you for the clarification! I have been using this list (a labor of love actually) for years and am grateful for all those who contributed and have kept it up! Thank you! 💜 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MELSMOM47 Posted March 9 #3178 Share Posted March 9 (edited) NEVERMIND. I found and figured out the spreadsheet. Having a little trouble searching. Any advice? TIA 🙏 Edited March 9 by MELSMOM47 found the answer Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
j3000 Posted March 16 #3179 Share Posted March 16 (edited) First visit to thus thread. I'm confused, cant figure out the spreadsheet (Im using ipad) It's probably not even on here, but I'm looking any comments on Reflection Room #6105. Can someone point me in the right direction? thanks! Edited March 16 by jargey3000 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
pd7277 Posted March 16 #3180 Share Posted March 16 (edited) 8 hours ago, jargey3000 said: First visit to thus thread. I'm confused, cant figure out the spreadsheet (Im using ipad) It's probably not even on here, but I'm looking any comments on Reflection Room #6105. Can someone point me in the right direction? thanks! The link to the spreadsheet is on the first page of this thread. There are no reviews on Cabin 6105, but those on Eclipse 6103 (next door) are not good. Instructions on using the spreadsheet is in a tab at the bottom of the spreadsheet. I've heard of people having problems on an ipad. If you found the spreadsheet, try using a laptop. This re noise: "Quiet whilst cruising BUT noisy from about 90 mins before docking. This cabin is directly above a platform that is lowered about 90 mins before docking and it makes a very loud and noticeable thud / bang vibrating in the cabin when they lower (or drop?) this platform. Additionally loud whirring noise can be heard during raising and lowering of anchor. There is also a crew access door near the cabin which seems to be used quite often by entertainment staff - no noise from within the cabin from the corridor or from the theatre below - sound insulation from theatre must be good." Edited March 16 by pd7277 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
j3000 Posted March 16 #3181 Share Posted March 16 thank you pd🙂 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CruiseDad-NYC Posted May 19 #3182 Share Posted May 19 SHIP NAME Eclipse CABIN # 1642 DECK # (3-14) 11 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV Aqua LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard stern BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Cabin was quiet, balcony was loud because of vent BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) great BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) standard with table and foot stool for lounger WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Was VERY unhappy with noise from the vent over the balcony door. It was an industrial fan that made being on the balcony unpleasant if you enjoy having breakfast or just enjoying the balcony in general. It also caused moisture to drip, and the table and floor was wet the whole time. If you don't make much use of your balcony, you may not notice. But, if you are someone who enjoys quality time on your balcony, definitely AVOID this cabin. It had a negative impact on our enjoyment of the cabin. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS April 20 - 27, 2024 20240425_091943.mp4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RainforestRoomer Posted May 23 #3183 Share Posted May 23 SHIP NAME Reflection CABIN # 9384 DECK # (3-14) 9 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV C1 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Stern-Aft BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Balcony QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Usually BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Great BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Oversized WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) Sometimes PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) While there was no noise from other cruisers or from above, the sound of engines when docking was so loud it shook me awake each morning the ship docked. The vibration was intense enough to shake me awake each time, like a minor earthquake. Would not book this room again just for that - no fun to be shaken awake at 6AM. Soot appeared on the balcony twice during the sailing, but easily wiped away. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
amyj23 Posted May 25 #3184 Share Posted May 25 (edited) SHIP NAME Eclipse CABIN # 8330 DECK # (3-14) 8 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV V-2 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard-Aft BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Balcony QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Yes BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Great BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard? We're Celebrity newbies, but this was one of the biggest balconies I've ever had on a cruise. Two chairs and a table and didn't feel cramped WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Probably a problem for all standard cabins on this ship, but storage is a problem. Lots of closet space, but very limited drawers. I had to hang my shorts which I've never done in my life. 😆 PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) NO idea why the bed pic is upside down. I’ve tried adding from my phone and computer. Sorry! I swear the bed is on the ground and not the ceiling in this cabin. DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS 5/11/24 Edited May 25 by amyj23 One of my pictures is upside down Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fawkes66 Posted June 25 #3185 Share Posted June 25 (edited) SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 1505 DECK # (3-14) 11 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV A2 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Port, Forward. BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Usually. Depending on the activity in the Aerobic room, directly above. Most activities are during day, when I was out. Guest relations acted adequately on too much noise (boxing) after 11pm BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Great view, also a nice view on the Bridge BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Except for the aerobic activities above no problems. Conveniently located near Spa, Relaxation Lounge and Persian Garden with easy access. The sockets shown on the picture below are the only ones available. I absolutely loved the shower and there was enough space for all my stuff in the bathroom. Missed a line to dry my bathing suit. There was enough closet space, with more than enough hangers and the drawers were large. I had two large suitcases which fitted under the bed Edited June 25 by Fawkes66 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rare wtang Posted July 14 #3186 Share Posted July 14 (edited) SHIP NAME Eclipse CABIN # 3130 DECK # (3-14) 3 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV O2 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard-Midship BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Yes BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) n/a BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) n/a WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) n/a SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) n/a PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Quiet cabin with easy access to the Moonlight Sonata MDR and the Eclipse Theater, both just one deck above. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS July 7-14, 2024 Edited July 14 by wtang 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cruisin lady ca Posted July 16 #3187 Share Posted July 16 SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 1546 DECK # (3-14) 11 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV AQ LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard Forward BED NEAR Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Usually BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Good BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Very close to forward elevators and stairs. Sometimes hear the "ding" of the elevators. Otherwise, no significant noise. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE COMMENTS 7/24/2024 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cruisin lady ca Posted July 16 #3188 Share Posted July 16 SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 9292 DECK # (3-14) 9 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV C1 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard Midship BED NEAR Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Yes BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Good BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Oversized WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) Very close to midship elevators. PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE COMMENTS 7/17/2024 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerelmx Posted August 2 #3189 Share Posted August 2 SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 2106 DECK # (3-14) 12 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV C1 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Starboard, Mid ship, Angled Balcony BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) YES BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Great, No Obstruction BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Big Angled Balcony WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS April 22, 2024 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gerelmx Posted August 2 #3190 Share Posted August 2 SHIP NAME Silhouette CABIN # 2101 DECK # (3-14) 12 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV C1 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Port side, Mid Ship BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Balcony QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) NO, Noise from upper deck BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) T much noise from upper deck PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS July 5, 2024 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LB_NJ Posted August 7 #3191 Share Posted August 7 Thank you for your contribution! SHIP NAME Eclipse CABIN # 1501 DECK # (3-14) 11 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV A2 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Port, Forward BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Usually, quiet for the whole trip except one day mid morning there were a number of loud thumps that lasted about 15 minutes. BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Good except bridge is down and to the right so it blocks some of the view in that direction. BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) Not really. Makes noise if you don't fully close the sliding glass door SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) not connecting. decent size bathroom. I liked the Aqua shower with multiple jets PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS 7/28/2024 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
catspaw1 Posted August 18 #3192 Share Posted August 18 SHIP NAME Eclipse CABIN # 6259 DECK # (3-14) 6 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV V3 LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) port about 10 cabins aft of aft staircase so a good location BED NEAR (Bath, Balcony, Window, N/A) balcony QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) yes BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) partial obstruction was no problem. Would choose again If offered at a much cheaper rate than regular balconies. BALCON SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) no SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) none but one day I came out of shower naked & a worker was painting the lifeboat right in front of u!. So close the curtains before taking a shower!So memo PICTURES (Attach pictures in your review) DATE OF CRUISE AND "REVOLUTION" COMMENTS July 7, 2025 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BeachTunes Posted September 17 #3193 Share Posted September 17 (edited) SHIP NAME Solstice CABIN # 9380 DECK # (3-14) 9 CATEGORY: 7-12, 1A-1C, 2A-2D, A1-A2, C1-C3, CS, FV, PS, RF, RS, S1-S2, SG, SV SC (Sunset Concierge Class) LOCATION ON SHIP: Port (left), Starboard (right), Bow (front), Stern (back) or Inside and Forward, Midship (between the forward and aft elevators), or Aft (For example: Port-Midship, Bow-Forward or Inside-Aft) Aft Cabin Overlooking Wake BED NEAR Bath QUIET? (Yes/No/Usually) Yes BALCONY VIEW (Good, Great, Obstructed?) Excellent! BALCONY SIZE (Standard, Oversized, Other) Standard WIND A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No SOOT A PROBLEM? (Yes/No/Sometimes) No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS (Explain all Noise (including crew door issues), Wind and Soot Problems here, plus all comments and information regarding things like connecting or accessible cabins) N/A PICTURES (Attach pictures in your reviews DATE OF CRUISE COMMENTS September 8 to 15, 2024 This stateroom was INCREDIBLE for our Alaskan sailing! The aft location blocked the wind and on sunny days with a temp of 15c/59f it actually felt hot! Highly recommended for an Alaskan itinerary. We saw whales from the balcony just before we left Icy Strait Point. Absolutely magical! No soot on our sailing but our stateroom attendant provided extra towels should it have been an issue. Loved this room very much as we like to get exercise during our cruises. It was approximately 130 steps to the midship elevators one-way. Those with mobility issues or who wish to be closer to elevators should book a room more midship or forward. Our stateroom attendant Ronaldo was the BEST! He always had a bucket of ice available as requested and serviced the room beautifully and efficiently. Take us back! 🙂 Edited September 17 by BeachTunes 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now