I can't speak to the aft facing cabins, but we have sailed several times on the side AQ cabins on Deck 11, generally those further forward. We never had any noise issues. On occasion, when sitting on our balcony, we could hear the movies above us, but as a muffled background noise which did not bother us at all. In warm sailings, we did have an issue with the lack of an overhang. On our last cruise in March to the Caribbean we rarely could use our balcony because of the sun shining down and the heat (and we love sitting out there, reading and just watching the sea go by). I would not hesitate to book those cabins on cooler sailings like Alaska, but I would think twice before booking them again in hot regions.