Jump to content
Cruise Critic Community


  • Content Count

  • Joined

About Stockjock

  • Rank
    Cool Cruiser

About Me

  • Location
    San Diego, CA USA
  • Interests
    Traveling, good food, nice wine, great company.
  • Favorite Cruise Line(s)
    Is there a bad one?
  • Favorite Cruise Destination Or Port of Call
    Have mostly done the Caribbean.

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. As mentioned, booked a 2021 cruise on Magnifica. Super cheap inside guarantee, and while we don't want an inside cabin, I figure I have at least a 50% shot at an upgrade. Do you agree with those odds? This cruise comes shortly after they stretch it, adding 200+ cabins and a couple of restaurants. So far, we've only been on MSC's relatively new ships, which have been very nice. This ship seems a bit older and not sure if they'll do much refurbishing during the "stretch", or if it's mostly just a stretch and not a lot else changes. I know MSC has stretched a couple of other ships in the past. Anyone have any experience with their stretched ships? Any other thoughts or comments, including thoughts on our inside GUAR roll of the dice?
  2. My loyalty points expired once and it was definitely annoying. We had a cruise booked that would have kept the 3 year clock running. MSC changed the date of sailing, the itinerary, the number of days drastically, even the continent (from Europe to South America) and never bothered to notify us in any way. Good thing I checked my online booking prior to the penalty period. I called MSC because I didn't want to lose my status points, plus I was annoyed at the changes without notification. They assured me they wouldn't take my points away, as the fact that we couldn't sail was due to their schedule change. Then, they took them away anyway! I've taken several cruises since then, including 2 in 2019 (Barcelona and Miami) with 2 more booked, (2020 and 2021) and worked my way back to gold. But I do understand that it can be irritating. Frankly, as mentioned, MSC's "status" doesn't really provide much of a benefit, so not the end of the world. There are pros and cons to MSC's loyalty program. Pros: 1. Status match. 2. Easier to reach a higher level. 3. Some of the Voyager's Club sailings are a great deal with double points and up to a 20% discount. Cons: 1. They can expire. 2. Benefits are of limited value. I've worked for one of the big Wall Street firms for 3 decades. We have certain status benefits, usually starting at $1,000,000 in total assets. If total household assets fall below that, due to withdrawals or market conditions, there's a grace period, but at some point, some of those perks may go away. So I guess I understand that perks don't necessarily last forever in every instance. Still, I remain annoyed that I lost my MSC points due to the issue described.
  3. So I booked a short cruise last night and placed a deposit which appeared to be fully refundable. This is not my first rodeo, as I’ve taken many cruises, so I looked very closely to make sure that my deposit was fully refundable, as I figured I have little to lose in the event that I need to cancel. There was no mention of any sort of penalty upon cancellation so I booked the cruise. Immediately after accepting payment, I received a message that the $200 deposit was nonrefundable. I didn’t take a screenshot the first time, so I went back and did an identical duplicate booking and if you look at the attached photo this is what I saw. There was no mention that I could see of any portion of the deposit which was nonrefundable. I’m not really putting up a stink right now, because I figure it’s not relevant unless I have to cancel, but it seems to me that this is pretty misleading. Do you agree or is there something I’m missing?
  4. We were there a couple of weeks ago. Due to the short time and late arrival, we just walked around Old San Juan, found a outdoor restaurant with live music, and had cocktails and appetizers.
  5. Not sure, but if you sailed recently, I've noticed that they often seem to forget about the 100 points you get for "confirming your details". So you could message Voyager's Club, reference the last sailing and state that they offered 100 points for confirming said details, you clicked through to do that, but you don't believe they were credited. I'd guess that you'd have a 50/50 chance that they'd add 100 points.
  6. I have not done yacht club, but I would presume that would be fine. I just got off of Seaside and I wore either slacks or nice quality jeans and a dress shirt most nights and a suit on elegant nights. But I don't think dockers and a polo shirt would have been at all out of place.
  7. I think they did a great job on the party. They obviously but quite a bit of time and energy into it. I would recommend it.
  8. Both are very nice. We preferred Divina, but that was about 3-4 years ago. We got off Seaside about a week ago.
  9. We had this package and yes we paid the gratuities, which did get annoying/old after a bit.
  10. I've submitted my review (4 stars) but it's not posted just yet. Here it is, for anyone interested. If you have any questions, feel free to ask. Also, I haven't spent much time proofreading this just yet, so feel free to point out spelling or grammatical errors. To begin, I have a love hate relationship with MSC. If you wish to find more details, you can search MSC Comedy of Errors on cruise critic's MSC forum for more information. I'll detail a few of them before I get into the meat of the review: 1. Booked a 4 night cruise out of Barcelona. We had sailed on Divina out of Rome 2 years prior. MSC changed the itinerary to a much longer cruise out of Brazil, but never informed us in any way about the change. No letter, no e-mail, no text, no phone call. When I finally found out, I called MSC, asked about losing status since the change was their fault and not mine. They told me I wouldn't lose status and then took away all of my Voyager's Club points. 2. Booked this cruise on Seaside. Package showed to be free drinks, but for some reason my sailing only included drinks at dinner. Later, better promotion including drinks anytime appeared. Was told I could change to the new promotion and keep the same nice midship balcony cabin. Moved to the new promo and they moved the cabin to a far less desirable room, very front of the ship, so less desirable location, apparently smaller, with a steel balcony (rather than the usual glass), and obviously it's hard to see through steel. Took months and an Act of God to get the problem fixed. Again, you can search through the rest of post as noted, but MSC's customer service has been hit and miss, with more miss than hit. That aside, we think their newer ships are beautiful and generally represent a good value, if you can get past the nagging customer service issues. Pro Tip: Once you have the cruise you want, try to avoid calling MSC customer service. They'll screw things up as often as not, if not more so. Now, onto the cruise review. MSC Seaside is a beautiful ship with some similarities to Bellissima but distinct differences as well. I'll touch upon some of those in the body of the review. Cabin: 4 stars. Quite comfortable, but not quite as good as Bellissima. Usually quiet, but we were on the 15th deck in Cabin 15113 right under the smaller Biscayne Bay buffet and during the day it was very noisy due to chairs being moved around. Fortunately it was quiet at night. There were some stains on the upholstery, but for the most part the room was in good shape. We found it to be a bit on the small side, like Bellissima, but it was large enough for our purposes. The cabin was mostly kept clean. However there were 2 nights where it was not cleaned and I'm still not sure why that was. Dining: I thought the food was quite good, better than on Bellissima or Divina. We were given lamb chops that were so wonderfully seasoned and cooked just perfectly. The same with respect to prime rib, just a perfect medium rare. I sent compliments to the chef on both occasions. The menus were often stained with oily food stains which was not so great. There was a heavy gasoline smell that permeated the Ipanema restaurant which I found to be quite foul. I asked staff about it. They said the smell came from a "diesel compressor" and it was the 2nd week that they'd had the problem. Not good. We found the Seaside restaurant to be nicer than Ipanema, which my girlfriend thought looked like a Denny's. The restaurants were nicer and restaurant service were better on Bellissima (which we sailed on in May out of Barcelona), but I think the food was better on Seaside. We enjoyed the food in the buffets and found it to be fresh and the variety reasonably good. Be aware than you may have a less crowded experience in the smaller Biscayne Bay buffet on the 16th deck. Less variety, but for breakfast it was similar to the larger buffet, but not as many people to fight your way though. Pro Tip: Things like New York steak, shrimp cocktail, Caesar Salad and salmon were available every night on the right side of the menu. The salmon was excellent as was the small but very fresh shrimp cocktail. The New York steak was pretty good, so if you don't see something you like on the left side, check out the "standard" options on the right side. Embarkation: We've had rapid and smooth embarkation and disembarkation experiences on all 3 of our MSC cruises. I think they do this very well. 5 stars. Entertainment: Entertainment was a mixed bag. Generally, we felt that the shows were disjointed and lacking in theme and quality. It seems like they said, "Hey, we've got a good guy who rolls around in a hoop and a couple of good roller skaters, so let's build shows around them". While I felt the Michael Jackson show was very good and the performer who played Jackson was excellent, many of the other cast members of all shows were just okay. The shows were much, much better on Bellissima. Also, I believe Seaside had recorded music in their shows where Bellissima had a live band. It made a big difference. We saw various other performers live throughout the ship. Not bad, but probably the worst of my 3 MSC cruises. On Divina, some of the performances and performers were amazing. I'm not a big opera guy, but there was an opera singer who was fantastic and a pianist who was incredibly talented. We didn't see much of that on Seaside. We thought they did a nice job on the Halloween party. Not as many passengers dancing as Bellissima, and the music could have been better. That might have played into things. Pro Tip: If you don't have a reservation for the show, you'll have to wait until the last 5 minutes to be seated and there won't be many seats left. So reserve the shows in advance. Fitness and Recreation: While I didn't use the gym, we did check it out and it appeared to be of a very high quality. Onboard Experience: Not sure what they're looking for, but I'd have to say that generally it was very good. We did have an engine failure our of St. Maarten which lasted for nearly 1 hour, but fortunately that didn't alter our schedule. Public Rooms: For the most part, spotlessly clean. They aren't as elegant as Divina or Bellissima, but generally pretty nice, in my view. I think Divina has the best soaring atrium, but they did have a fairly high atrium on Seaside. While Bellissima didn't have a soaring atrium, it does have that great promenade with a high-resolution ceiling, which was missing on Seaside. I think future ships should add the same promenade but also feature the soaring atrium where the lit elevators glide gracefully up and down the various decks. Service: Staff: On Divina, we had a snotty Eastern European staff who seemed like they hated their life, hated their jobs and hated their passengers. Things had improved on Bellissima and the service level was quite high. My girlfriend is from the Philippines and I've suggested that they should hire more Filipinos. They are a hard working people and very naturally friendly, for the most part. They did just that. While frankly, I thought the service was a bit better on Bellissima, the staff was super friendly on Seaside, which made for a more enjoyable experience. In terms of the bars, they couldn't make a decent cocktail on Bellissima. The same drink tasted wildly different from one bar to the next. On Seaside, the drinks were sometimes on the weak side, but at least the quality was consistent. Pro Tip: If you don't like your restaurant assignment, see the Matire 'D and see him early. We had a 5 pm dinner seating which I changed to 9:30 pm. The Maitre 'D on Seaside was a nice guy, but on Bellissima he was a total jerk. A Gripe and Suggestion: We had the easy drink package that provided basic drinks. If you wanted something fancier, you had to pay for the entire cocktail. I suggest that MSC allow credit for the basic drinks towards the fancier ones. So if the general limit for an easy package drink is $6 and one wishes to buy a drink costing $10, charge the customer $4 rather than the full $10 since they do have a drink package already in place. Shore Excursions: We only did one of MSC's shore excursions and that was the "Sweet St. Maarten, Maho and Marigot". For the most part, this tour was enjoyable and was a good value. But I could have skipped the visit to the ice cream shop, where you had to buy your own ice cream. I guess it did give one an opportunity for a restroom break. While I did enjoy the tour, our bus broke down in sweltering heat. So we're sitting diagonally in the middle of the main road, largely blocking both lanes of traffic. Oh, and no air conditioner either. And if that wasn't bad enough, everyone was honking their horns at us and police had to be called to direct traffic around our disabled bus. They did eventually get us another bus, but it was an uncomfortable experience and limited my ability to shop in the ports. In fact, I lost a dress I purchased for my girlfriend, in part, because I was rushed due to the bus' mechanical failure issue. Normally I'd give our excursion a 4 rating, but I'll knock off 1 star and a 3 is generous in light of the bus breakdown. Value for Money: I'd probably give it 5 stars. As noted, the newer MSC ships are gorgeous, the service was pretty good, food is getting better. I think that if you can put up with some funky customer service issues and a glitch here and there, MSC represents a very good value. We currently have a cruise booked next year and in 2021. Cabin: As mentioned, it was clean but on the small side. No cabin service for 2 our of 7 days. Body wash not replaced for 3 days. For the first 2 days, they apparently used shampoo for body wash and diluted it about 75% with water so it was the consistency of water. Most cabin stewards only had shampoo or body wash, not both (I looked at their carts). Some stains on upholstery but not too bad. Lots of noise from upstairs buffet during the day. Closet too small, could use more storage. C450826C-3B9F-4471-8882-BB0928E7F929.heic 740A6358-7B2D-4549-9D26-A82A292E8B1F.heic C4EF3A0F-FDDB-404A-AA22-E8A1091145F2.heic D757EF4E-EA0F-427A-9E78-0B1BCE2E3029.heic E2B33D0C-D17D-4A01-B2CF-9BF40AC048D2.heic
  • Create New...