Compare And vote

[nimiq]

Hello all,

I would like your opinion on a comparison

Of some carnival ships.

 

I will be on the Liberty in less than 20 days

and would like to see which ship you have

Preferred to the ones I was on or will be sailing.

Carnival Liberty "with the new upgrade"

Carnival Miracle

Carnival Victory

Carnival Elation

Please tell me out of these for what's your favorite and

why ? Please only answer if you have been on the 4

ships.

 

I for myself will let you know upon my return from

Carnival Liberty.

Sea ya

Eric

[CanWeGoYet?]

haha, thought this was about the election for a moment.

 

Nothing from me, have only been on the Liberty.

[gail811]

I have been on 3 of the 4 ships.

The Miracle is my favorite ship, and favorite class of ship in the Carnival fleet.

I LOVED the Liberty and the changes. I would sail either of the two again in a heartbeat!

My first cruise was on the Victory so I have fond memories, but have not had the chance to sail her again.

[k2excursion]

I've only been on 2 of those ships. The Miracle has been my least favorite of all the ships I've been on. The Elation was one of my favorites. I liked the Victory's sister ship, Triumph, but Elation was better. I've been on 2 of Liberty's sister ships. She would probably be my new favorite of the 4 you listed if I were to sail her (not because of the 2.0 stuff, but because I like the style).

[Rena921]

Been on 3 of the 4. Miracle was our first so it will always hold a special place, I love Liberty - it's bigger so there are more places to get lost. Elation was fine for a smaller older ship, however i Liked Ectasy better. Out of all of them, I prefer Liberty.

[nimiq]

So far its looks like I made a good choice in

booking the Liberty :-)

[gfy012]

Liberty even before the upgrade.

[serene56]

Out of the 4- I prefer Miracle.

 

Sailed Liberty twice, so I am over that one. We booked the GLory-- new upgrades and same layout as the Liberty.

 

sailed Victory 2 times-- very green.

 

 

We have only had one bad cruise

[SkyMaster]

I'd vote for "Liberty". GREAT cruise. "Miracle" is a wonderful ship, but the Cruise Director (Malcolm) is the worlds worst. You won't go wrong with "Liberty".

 

"SKY"

[nimiq]

Tanks all,

You are so nice for taking the time to answer.

As for my past experience on these 3 first ship I must say my favorite is Miracle.

1 Miracle-love the layout and decor.

2 Elation-like the size and maybe 2nd as it was our ever first cruise on Carnival and love it.

3-Victory-was very good as well but someone had to be third lol.

 

Now just have to wait and see where I will place the Liberty after our sailing.

 

Sea ya

Eric

[Ykgorbie]

I have been on the Miracle and most recently, Liberty. I think you might get back from the cruise pleasantly surprised that it is your new favorite ship !

[gusandgidgetsmom]

Liberty any time! Even before upgrades. My favorite of any ship except the Mardi Gras and that was only because when I started cruising she was the only one around and was the reason I got hooked on cruising !