Pies

[lovestocruise19]

DH and I were looking over the new American Table menu and when I read the pie a la mode for the table he started drooling. :p

 

He wants to know, for those of you that have had the new menu, is it a whole pie for the table (some nights it doesn't say for the table) and what kinds. Apple, blueberry, cherry, cream pies?

 

Thanks! The new menu actually looks pretty good so hopefully we'll have it on our Jan. 2 cruise on the Valor.

[funinthesun1964]

DH and I were looking over the new American Table menu and when I read the pie a la mode for the table he started drooling. :p

 

He wants to know, for those of you that have had the new menu, is it a whole pie for the table (some nights it doesn't say for the table) and what kinds. Apple, blueberry, cherry, cream pies?

 

Thanks! The new menu actually looks pretty good so hopefully we'll have it on our Jan. 2 cruise on the Valor.

 

We were on the Liberty last month. I don't care for pie, but DH ordered the apple pie one night. He said it was VERY good. It seems to me they had a different type of fruit pie every night. I know they had peach another night. Although I don't recall any of the cream pies.

[nicoleds]

on glory we had the pie a few times, apple, blueberry, strawberry rhubarb. They were all very good, it was a different pie each night.

[love my grandkids]

Blueberry is very good. Didnt care for rhubarb but generally not a rhubarb fan so not Carnivval's fault

[SadieN]

It's changed from whole pie for the table to plated slices.

[lovestocruise19]

Ah, okay, that's what I thought that they did away with the for the table. DH is sad he can't get a whole pie. Lol. I told him to order multiple slices.

[KatPem]

I thought it was for the table and wasn't going to order due to that until my husband ordered it. Apple was the first night...it is my all-time favorite Carnival dessert!!!! Peach was the second or third night, my husband liked this even better than the apple. The last night was cherry. They had rhubarb, and blueberry and I think that was it but can't remember their order. Pretty sure they didn't have it on elegant nights.

[lovestocruise19]

Awesome! My DH likes apple, blueberry and cherry.

[Elaine5715]

Pie lovers, what for the Key Lime pie on the lunch buffet...so good. It never is on the dining room menu so get it while you can.

[lovestocruise19]

I myself love key lime pie and have had it at the buffet. They have something called key lime mousse on the new menu. Wonder if that will be any good.

[MrMileStoner]

Even when it was listed for the whole table I never saw them bring out a whole pie. They brought out slices and it is good.

[lovestocruise19]

Even when it was listed for the whole table I never saw them bring out a whole pie. They brought out slices and it is good.

Oh, okay. Well, I'm sure DH will be happy nonetheless because it seems like they have pie quite often on the new menus. Hopefully the Valor will have the new menus in January and they won't wait until her dry dock in March.

Edited April 21, 2015 by lovestocruise19

[SadieN]

They'd bring out a whole pie if there were enough to share it.

[jimbo5544]

I tried a couple diffreent ones on our 4/5 Breeze sailing. Apple was OK, cherry was much better.

[MCFTJCH2V]

Of course all I'm craving now is pie.

[Frank12]

Of course all I'm craving now is pie.

I was thinking the same thing! :p

[jimbo5544]

Of course all I'm craving now is pie.

 

LOL, there are worse things to crave... although not according to my scale when we returned from our cruise.....

[Seany527]

Awesome! My DH likes apple, blueberry and cherry.

 

Here's the apple and the blueberry.

 

"][/url]

 

"][/url]

[sanmarcosman]

The fruit pies on the AT menu are of Mrs. Smith's quality.