Carnival Magic or Oasis of the seas

[katiel53]

Oasis for sure. Many people assume the ship will be crowded because of the high number of passengers. I haven't sailed Oasis, but did her sister, Allure. Other than the first day when everyone was boarding, I didn't find it as crowded as some of the Carnival ships I have sailed.

 

I was surprised that someone posted that Carnival has more dining venues than Oasis and I have found that not to be true on Allure. There are many places to have lunch and although both have a main dining room for dinner, there are other included places like the Lido to have food at dinnertime. I didn't notice that Carnival had more than the Lido or main dining room for dinner other than the specialty restaurants and Oasis has far more of them than Carnival.

 

To me, there are many advantages to sailing on Allure over Carnival, but I do sail both lines and enjoy them both.

[riclop]

Oasis all the way.

[easyboy]

Oasis is the choice!

[Aquahound]

I know this is an old thread but I'll still throw in my .02. Oasis Class has still yet to meet their match from any other cruise line. So....I definitely recommend Oasis!