If Not Hal, Which Cruise Line?

[jazzsea]

Let's suppose you are planning a cruise and it cannot be on Holland America. Which cruise line would you like to try? And because it is Friday, money is no object. Which cruise line and why?

[Krazy Kruizers]

Either:

Cunard - have been on several Cunard ships including the QE 2 and definitely want to try the QM 2.

OR

Crystal - friends have done several cruises and said that they prefer Crystal over HAL.

[lgt]

After 7 HAL cruises, we tried Princess this summer. Loved it. Was a little more casual, big, huge ship, wonderful suite & great service. Picked the Golden because of the itinerary. Will be back on HAL in the spring.

[cruise freak]

I love Hal but also really enjoy Celebrity. Try one of their M class ship and you will love it.

[RuthC]

Let's suppose you are planning a cruise and it cannot be on Holland America. Which cruise line would you like to try? And because it is Friday, money is no object. Which cruise line and why?

O-o-o-o. That's a toughie. Money no object? I do like the sound of that so let's get thinking here.

 

It's easier to know what lines I don't want to book. Carnival, NCL, Disney, and Princess are definitely out; probably RCL, too. I might be willing to give Cunard another try; perhaps I was just too young for their style when I sailed that line.

 

I'd be back at the begining of time researching the various lines to determine atmosphere, demographic, food and entertainment. Certainly I'd be looking at Celebrity, Crystal, and Seabourn as they appear to have a refined atmosphere.

I'd also look at Oceania for their smaller ships, and possibly a cruise on the Marco Polo for itinerary.

[thulewx]

Radisson. Tried Crystal - wasn't that impressed :rolleyes: . I've done Radisson twice, leaving for #3 next week - superb - much better than HAL - service, food, everything. And considering the No Tippiing ALLOWED policy along with most booze free, prices are actually comparable if you find one on sale.

Or possibly, I'd go back to the QM2, and since it's money-no-object, Queen's Grill Royal suite (at around $8000 a day per couple :eek: ).

[xsnowman99]

I would definitely choose WindStar Line...if fact, we are working on booking a New year's cruise with them. HAL was a great line...just too big for us. But, any cruise is a great trip!!

[TedC]

Radisson sounds very appealing.

[localady]

I think RSSC would be my choice too, but pull my arm and I am happy to try Seabourn, Viking (for River cruising), and Clipper or Windstar. If anyone needs a "guinea pig", I volunteer!!!:D

[torpeedo]

Money is no object! Silver Cloud. Beautifully appointed luxury ship with all inclusive fare. Unique ports.:D

[bdmarine]

I'll vote for Silversea also, the Whisper or the Shadow. If you find a 50% discount sailing and remember that all your booze is free, then you might even find out it's cheaper than S on Holland.

 

Plus no photographers!

[ekerr19]

I am thinking of gicing Celebrity a try - we have also looked closely at RSSC. Our TA is always sending us their brochures and the ships and itineraries look fantastic.

[RevNeal]

I would cruise on Celebrity, Radisson, and Cunard. :)

If money truly were no option, cruise-life would be REAL interesting. I've tried convincing God that I could do a lot more for Him if He were to make me a multimillionaire ... I'm still waiting for a reply. :D

[jhannah]

If money were no object, my first choice would be QM2. Then I'd also like to try Raddison. But on my current budget, I sail HAL and Princess. I would like to give Celebrity a try for comparison. So many ships ... so little time (and $$$$.) ;)

[jhannah]

I've tried convincing God that I could do a lot more for Him if He were to make me a multimillionaire ... I'm still waiting for a reply. :D

My call was answered ... but I've been put on hold! :)

[dakrewser]

Windstar for the ambience, Oceania for the itineraries and - if money truly is no object, a Queen's Grille cabin on the QE2 for their January NYC-Southampton, the Long Way...

[dst]

personally still my fav is RCCL......great cruise and very nice ships :)

 

However I'd cruise any line to get a cruise

[Druke I]

I prefer Princess, primarily for their wide range of itineraries.

 

Hope to take Prinsendam through the Kiel Canal into the Baltic, Sep 05.

 

Michael

[saltydog28]

If money were no object, I would have my own yacht, and the crew to go with it.

Take care,

Pat.

[jazzsea]

I've been thinking all day, every since I posted this question. Which one would I choose? I've sailed on all the cruise lines except Disney, Seabourn and Silver Seas. I loved Radisson for the cabins but thought the guests were a little snooty. I hated NCL and thought the cabins way too small on RCL. I've sailed on Marco Polo and loved the itineraries. Ship was okay, but it is much older than I care for. I love Windstar to pieces. Princess ships are too big. So, I suppose I would choose Crystal. I liked the Oceania Insignia but wasn't crazy about the staff. Food was yummy, yummy, though.

 

The best vacation I have ever had was on a B2B Wind Surf last March.