The AMA Waterways cruises that I am pricing out are definitely lower priced than when I compare pricing to an inside cabin on Celebrity with drink packages, excursions, room service, and chefs table. Plus you know that you are going to run into other fees on Celebrity such as additional fees for wine with the drink package, etc., etc.
AMA Waterways does not have any inside cabins to compare with. I had zero additional charges on AMA Waterways.
This kind of reminds me of the discount airlines. Celebrity's prices are low, but when you add in everything they can be more expensive.
Trying to get around the high drink prices, corkage fees by pouring in the room is probably not the way to go...
Skip drinks on Celebrity, excursions, and chefs table and Celebrity would be less expensive.