Having just got off the Magic 2 weeks before you got on, I would have to agree with just about everything you posted. There was nothing horrible, but nothing spectacular either. Your piano player sounded far better than ours, though.
Your comment about the loungers was spot on. We actually saw a rather large man go right through it one day. Luckily he wasn't injured but he was pretty embarrassed. Other than that we thought the ship was in pretty good shape for how old it is.
Thanks for taking the time to do the review. It was a real pleasure to read. 🙂