My first Carnival experience was NYC on Splendor in Feb, 2014 and sailed 5X that year on Splendor. Miss those winter sailings on Carnival from NYC big time.
No interest in cruises in summer from anywhere. Maybe someday it will happen again for winters in NYC.
In the meantime, I'll settle for winter cruises from Baltimore, unless I want to fly to cruise or go on another line from NY or NJ.