I think the OP made some valid points, and some, not so much. Info about upcharges, MTD etc was all available well in advance and were on the app, so there should be no surprises. It’s great that you had such a positive experience, but I think the OP had some valid concerns.
I was on your sailing. We had a good time (we hadn’t cruised since way before Covid), but there were definitely some issues. Sure; chair hogging is everywhere, but it’s still annoying. No toilet seat covers is NOT okay and most of the public restrooms did not smell clean. That’s not something I can shrug off. Most of the Purell stations needed refills. Definitely not ok. There were a number of other issues, noticeable, but not enough to spoil our trip or even bother listing here. I’m not a nit picker, but there was a definite difference in service/staffing to us since our last cruise, and I understand COVID has taken its toll.
RCI is the only cruise line we’ve sailed and this was our first cruise as Diamonds—we really really liked the daily drink vouchers, and many other positive aspects. We will likely never reach D+ so we may consider other cruise lines to see what’s out there. It won’t be NCL or Carnival, but maybe Virgin.
teddie