Celebrity does well in latest Conde' Nast Polls

[gelo7]

Top 20 Large Cruise Ships

 

 

 

 

 

 

1. Disney Magic, Disney, 90.7
   
2. Celebrity Eclipse, Celebrity, 88.8
   
3. Disney Dream, Disney, 88.8
   
4. Disney Wonder, Disney, 88.8
   
5. Celebrity Equinox, Celebrity, 88.3
   
6. Queen Mary 2, Cunard, 86.2
   
7. Celebrity Solstice, Celebrity, 86.0
   
8. Diamond Princess, Princess, 83.9
   
9. Independence of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 83.7
   
10. Oasis of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 83.4
    
11. Ruby Princess, Princess, 83.0
    
12. Sapphire Princess, Princess, 83.0
    
13. Liberty of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 82.8
    
14. Emerald Princess, Princess, 82.3
    
15. Freedom of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 82.1
    
16. Adventure of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 81.3
    
17. Mariner of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 80.7
    
18. Star Princess, Princess, 80.5
    
19. Grand Princess, Princess, 80.0
    
20. Voyager of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 80.0
    

[cruise47]

Looks like Celebrity and RCI did very well in the Conde' Nast Poll.

 

Ten (10) of the Top Twenty ships are either Celebrity or RCI.

 

However, Disney Cruise Lines had three (3) of the Top four (4) cruise ships.

 

Ranked 1, 3, & 4.

[leonardofan]

But did you see the recommendations at the World Ocean and Cruise Liner

Society?:eek:

 

Never mind, what counts is Berlitz...:p

[CactusGirly]

What's interesting is if they would have categorized it and pulled out "Family Friendly", Celebrity would have likely been in the #1 & 2 spots.

 

To be clear, I am not discounting DCL. We have cruised on that line before, and will again in a few months. They do provide an outstanding experience and beautiful ships, but it is definitely a niche market.

[gelo7]

Looks like Celebrity and RCI did very well in the Conde' Nast Poll.

 

Ten (10) of the Top Twenty ships are either Celebrity or RCI.

 

However, Disney Cruise Lines had three (3) of the Top four (4) cruise ships.

 

Ranked 1, 3, & 4.

Yes, Disney did very well.

[KirkNC]

I wonder where Allure is?

[YOW]

Seems odd to have Disney Magic and Disney Wonder in the 'large' category -- they're actually smaller than some ships in the 'medium' list such as Constellation and Summit.

 

And how readers could put Eurodam on the same level as Oceania or Azamara ships, I'll never know. :rolleyes:

[jacketwatch]

Top 20 Large Cruise Ships

 

 

 

 

 

 

1. Disney Magic, Disney, 90.7
   
2. Celebrity Eclipse, Celebrity, 88.8
   
3. Disney Dream, Disney, 88.8
   
4. Disney Wonder, Disney, 88.8
   
5. Celebrity Equinox, Celebrity, 88.3
   
6. Queen Mary 2, Cunard, 86.2
   
7. Celebrity Solstice, Celebrity, 86.0
   
8. Diamond Princess, Princess, 83.9
   
9. Independence of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 83.7
   
10. Oasis of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 83.4
    
11. Ruby Princess, Princess, 83.0
    
12. Sapphire Princess, Princess, 83.0
    
13. Liberty of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 82.8
    
14. Emerald Princess, Princess, 82.3
    
15. Freedom of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 82.1
    
16. Adventure of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 81.3
    
17. Mariner of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 80.7
    
18. Star Princess, Princess, 80.5
    
19. Grand Princess, Princess, 80.0
    
20. Voyager of the Seas, Royal Caribbean, 80.0
    

I saw that as well. Very impressive. Hopefully we will be on the Equinox next fall. :)

[snaebyllej]

Seems odd to have Disney Magic and Disney Wonder in the 'large' category -- they're actually smaller than some ships in the 'medium' list such as Constellation and Summit.

 

Over or under 2500 passengers.

[SoBe2010]

I saw that as well. Very impressive. Hopefully we will be on the Equinox next fall. :)

 

Is Princess really that good? We avoided them so far. The cabins look very old fashioned. Food reviews are not very good.